The Google rating average for roofing companies is about 4.45 stars in 2026, based on ReplyOnTheFly benchmark data, slightly below HVAC (4.55) and plumbing (4.52) but above the broad home-services floor of 4.2 stars reported by Little Nudge. Ratings shift by state with metro density, storm frequency, and the share of roofing work done by transient operators, so the state ranking below uses four modeled bands from about 4.2 to 4.6 stars.
By The Roofing Brief Team. Last reviewed: October 2026.
What is the average Google star rating for roofing contractors?
The average roofing contractor in the United States carries roughly 4.45 Google stars, per ReplyOnTheFly’s 2026 industry benchmarks. That sits inside the home-services band, where HVAC averages 4.55, plumbing 4.52, electricians 4.50, landscaping 4.48, and pest control 4.40. Little Nudge’s 2026 data puts the broad home-services average lower at 4.2 stars, so 4.4 to 4.5 is a defensible national midpoint for roofers.
Roofing rates 0.10 stars below HVAC (4.55, per ReplyOnTheFly 2026) for a structural reason. A roof replacement is a high-ticket, weather-exposed job where delays, surprise deck rot, and insurance-claim friction are common, and each dispute can produce a 1-star review that pulls the average down.
National roofer rating benchmark by trade
Roofing sits mid-pack among the skilled trades on Google. The table below shows 2026 average ratings and typical review counts by trade, so a homeowner can judge whether a local roofer’s profile is normal, strong, or a red flag. All figures are from ReplyOnTheFly’s 2026 benchmarks except the home-services floor, which is from Little Nudge (2026).
| Trade | Avg Google rating (2026) | Typical review count |
|---|---|---|
| HVAC | 4.55 | 40 to 120 |
| Plumbing | 4.52 | 30 to 100 |
| Electricians | 4.50 | 25 to 90 |
| Landscaping | 4.48 | 20 to 80 |
| Roofing | 4.45 | 25 to 75 |
| Cleaning services | 4.43 | 20 to 70 |
| Pest control | 4.40 | 25 to 80 |
| Home services (broad average) | 4.20 | Not reported |
Review volume is where roofing profiles vary most. A single-metro sample of 119 roofing contractors in North Carolina’s Triangle region held 15,917 Google reviews combined, a median of 83 reviews per contractor and an average of 134, with individual ratings spanning 2.3 to 5.0 stars (Triangle Roofing Report, June 2026). Ratings cluster tightly near the top while review counts spread wide, so volume is often the more useful signal. Outside the Triangle, we rank certified North Carolina roofers in Burlington and Hickory.
Reading a roofer’s Google profile
| If the profile shows | Then |
|---|---|
| 4.5 stars or higher with 83 or more reviews | Strong: above the 4.45 average and the Triangle median |
| 4.2 to 4.5 stars | Competitive: between the home-services average and the roofer average |
| Under 4.0 stars | Caution: 0.45 or more stars below the national roofer average |
| Fewer than 25 reviews | Thin sample, whatever the average: the typical roofer carries 25 to 75 |
| Several recent 1-star reviews citing callbacks or claims | Weigh them above the headline average |
Roofer ratings by state: the reputation-pressure ranking
No public source scrapes and publishes an average Google rating for every roofing contractor in all 50 states, so the four-tier state ranking below (bands from about 4.2 to 4.6 stars, anchored to the 4.45 average from ReplyOnTheFly 2026) is a modeled directional estimate, not a raw census. It anchors to the 4.45-star national roofer average (ReplyOnTheFly, 2026) and adjusts each state up or down using three named public inputs: storm and hail frequency, roofing-contractor density, and complaint exposure. The method is described in full under Methodology.
The core finding: high-catastrophe states with heavy storm-chaser activity tend to sit below the national average and carry the widest rating spread, while stable, lower-catastrophe markets with established firms tend to sit at or above it. Review volume runs highest in large Sun Belt metros regardless of average rating.
| Tier | Representative states | Modeled avg rating band | Review-volume tier | Primary driver |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Above national average | Utah, Idaho, Oregon, Wisconsin, Virginia, Washington | ~4.5 to 4.6 | Moderate | Lower storm turnover, established firms |
| At national average | California, Arizona, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Michigan | ~4.4 to 4.5 | High (large metros) | High volume dilutes individual disputes |
| Slightly below average | Florida, Georgia, Tennessee, Missouri, Illinois | ~4.3 to 4.4 | High | Storm claims and permit friction |
| Below national average | Texas, Colorado, Oklahoma, Nebraska, Louisiana | ~4.2 to 4.4 | Very high | Hail Alley storm-chaser churn, dispute-driven 1-star reviews |
The lowest tier maps almost exactly onto hail exposure. Nebraska averages about 534 hail events a year and Colorado about 414 (Insurify, 2026), while Texas carries the highest annual hail losses at roughly $338.6 million, ahead of Colorado at $151 million and Nebraska at $50.8 million (MoneyGeek/Insurify, 2026). Those same states draw transient post-storm operators whose short local histories and claim disputes tend to depress average ratings. For the mechanics of that churn, see our storm-chaser exposure report by state.
Why storm states rate lower than stable states
Roofers in high-hail states such as Nebraska (534 hail events a year, per Insurify 2026) model at 4.2 to 4.4 stars, below the 4.45 national anchor, because catastrophe cycles pull transient operators into the market and turn a share of jobs into insurance disputes. After a major hail event, out-of-state crews arrive, sell fast, and often leave before warranty issues surface. Unresolved claims and abandoned callbacks convert directly into 1-star Google reviews, which weigh heavily against the handful of 5-star reviews a new local profile has.
Texas, Florida, and California hold the most roofing contractors of any states (ConsumerAffairs, 2026), out of roughly 113,000 US roofing businesses in a $103.6 billion market (IBISWorld, 2026). Dense competition raises review volume everywhere, but in storm-heavy states it also raises the rate of low-star disputes. This ratings pattern parallels, but is distinct from, formal complaint data. We track that separately in our best and worst states for roofing complaints report.
What counts as a good star rating and review count for a roofer?
A roofer at or above 4.5 stars is strong, 4.2 to 4.5 is competitive, and anything under 4.0 should prompt caution, since that sits 0.45 stars below the 4.45 ReplyOnTheFly national average. Star rating alone can mislead, so weigh it against volume: the Triangle Roofing Report sample ran from 2.3 to 5.0 stars with a median of 83 reviews.
- Rating floor: 4.2 stars to stay competitive, 4.5-plus to lead the local pack (ReplyOnTheFly, 2026).
- Volume floor: a metro roofer typically clears a median near 83 reviews (Triangle Roofing Report, 2026); treat fewer than 25 as a thin sample.
- Recency: a profile whose newest review is more than a year old discounts a high rating, because the 4.45 average (ReplyOnTheFly 2026) reflects current service, not history.
- Spread: a cluster of recent 1-star reviews mentioning callbacks or claims matters more than the headline average.
Check any profile against the 25-review floor and the 4.2-star Little Nudge line above, then follow the vetting steps in how to get a new roof. Contractors benchmarking their own acquisition economics can compare the roofing cost per lead benchmark.
Methodology
The state ranking is a model; the ReplyOnTheFly national anchor (4.45 stars) and the Triangle Roofing Report metro sample (119 contractors, 15,917 reviews) are cited directly. The 50-state rating bands are modeled estimates, because no public dataset reports a verified average Google rating for every roofing contractor by state, and individual contractors vary within any state.
- National anchor. The 4.45-star roofer average and per-trade comparison come from ReplyOnTheFly’s 2026 Google-review benchmarks, cross-checked against Little Nudge’s 2026 home-services average of 4.2 stars.
- Volume anchor. Review-count norms use ReplyOnTheFly’s 25-to-75 roofing range and the Triangle Roofing Report (June 2026), a real single-metro sample of 119 contractors and 15,917 reviews (median 83, average 134).
- State adjustment. Each state is shifted from the 4.45 anchor (ReplyOnTheFly 2026) into one of four bands (about 4.2 to 4.6) using storm and hail frequency (Insurify and MoneyGeek, 2026), roofing-contractor density (ConsumerAffairs and IBISWorld, 2026), and complaint exposure from our own state complaint tracking.
- Consumer thresholds. The 4.0, 4.2, and 4.5 cutoffs are editorial bands set against the 4.45 anchor and the 4.2 home-services average; BrightLocal‘s annual Local Consumer Review Survey is the standing reference for how consumers use review ratings.
Limitation: Google ratings measure public sentiment and review-gathering effort, not roofing quality, licensing, or complaint history, and the Triangle Roofing Report sample alone spans 2.3 to 5.0 stars. Treat the state bands (about 4.2 to 4.6) as expected ranges, not per-contractor scores.
Key findings
- The average US roofing contractor holds about 4.45 Google stars in 2026 (ReplyOnTheFly), just below HVAC (4.55) and plumbing (4.52).
- Roofers sit above the broad home-services floor of 4.2 stars (Little Nudge, 2026) but the trade’s dispute exposure keeps it out of the top rank.
- Review volume varies far more than star rating: a Triangle-region sample showed a median of 83 reviews per contractor and a range of 2.3 to 5.0 stars (Triangle Roofing Report, 2026).
- High-hail states such as Texas, Colorado, Oklahoma, and Nebraska model below the national average, tracking Nebraska’s 534 and Colorado’s 414 annual hail events, with modeled bands of 4.2 to 4.4 against the 4.45-star anchor (ReplyOnTheFly 2026; Insurify 2026).
- Stable, lower-catastrophe states such as Utah, Idaho, and Wisconsin model at or above average.
- Texas, Florida, and California hold the most roofing contractors (ConsumerAffairs, 2026), which lifts review volume but widens the dispute-driven rating spread.
Reviewed by The Roofing Brief Team. Last reviewed: October 2026.
Frequently asked questions
What is the average Google star rating for roofing contractors?
The average US roofing contractor holds about 4.45 Google stars in 2026, per ReplyOnTheFly’s benchmarks. That is just below HVAC at 4.55 and plumbing at 4.52, and above the broad home-services floor of 4.2 stars reported by Little Nudge. A defensible national midpoint for roofers is 4.4 to 4.5 stars.
Which states have the highest-rated roofers?
Modeled estimates place stable, lower-catastrophe states such as Utah, Idaho, Oregon, and Wisconsin in the 4.5 to 4.6 band, at or above the 4.45-star national average (ReplyOnTheFly 2026). These markets have less storm-driven contractor turnover, so established firms accumulate steady reviews with fewer claim disputes. No public source verifies an exact average for every state, so treat these as directional bands.
Do roofers in storm states have lower ratings?
On average, yes. High-hail states such as Texas, Colorado, Oklahoma, and Nebraska model at 4.2 to 4.4, below the 4.45-star national average (ReplyOnTheFly 2026), because catastrophe cycles draw transient storm-chaser crews and turn a share of jobs into insurance disputes. Unresolved claims and abandoned callbacks convert into 1-star reviews that weigh heavily against a new local profile’s few 5-star reviews.
What is a good star rating for a roofer?
A roofer at or above 4.5 stars is strong, 4.2 to 4.5 is competitive, and under 4.0 should prompt caution, 0.45 stars below the 4.45 national average (ReplyOnTheFly 2026). Weigh the rating against review volume, since a high average on fewer than 25 reviews is a thin signal.
How many Google reviews should a roofing company have?
National benchmarks put a typical roofer at 25 to 75 reviews (ReplyOnTheFly, 2026), while a metro sample showed a median near 83 (Triangle Roofing Report, 2026). Treat fewer than 25 as a thin sample, and weight recent reviews above an old total.