Subscribe

MATERIALS · July 28, 2026

Aluminum vs Steel Roofing: Cost, Lifespan, and Which to Pick

Aluminum vs steel roof: aluminum runs $7 to $17/sq ft installed vs $5 to $13 for steel (HomeGuide 2025). Coastal 1-mile rule, lifespan, and which to pick.

By The Roofing Brief Team. Last reviewed: October 2026.

The choice in aluminum vs steel roofing comes down to one question: how close do you live to salt air. Aluminum never rusts and wins in coastal and high-humidity climates, while steel is stronger, cheaper, and resists denting better, which makes it the default for inland homes in hail, snow, and wind country. Sheffield Metals does not offer paint or substrate warranties on Galvalume steel within 1,500 feet of a coast, and Western States Metal Roofing recommends aluminum over steel for any project within one mile of the ocean. Inland, HomeGuide’s November 2025 pricing puts galvanized or Galvalume steel at $5 to $13 per sq ft installed against $7 to $17 for aluminum.

Aluminum vs steel roofing at a glance

Aluminum and steel are the two most common metal roofing substrates for homes. Aluminum carries no metallic coating because its own oxide film blocks red rust, per Sheffield Metals’ Galvalume vs aluminum guide. Steel relies on a hot-dipped coating: Galvalume is 55% aluminum, 43.4% zinc and 1.6% silicon, applied at AZ50 (0.50 oz per sq ft, both sides combined) for painted coil or AZ55 for bare coil, per the same guide. Every row below names its source.

Factor Aluminum roofing Steel roofing Source
Installed cost $7 to $17 per sq ft ($700 to $1,700 per square) $5 to $13 per sq ft (galvanized or Galvalume) HomeGuide, Nov 2025
Material only, corrugated $3.50 to $5.50 per sq ft $1.50 to $4.50 per sq ft Western States Metal Roofing, Jan 2023
Material only, standing seam $4.50 to $6.50 per sq ft $2.50 to $5.00 per sq ft Western States Metal Roofing, Jan 2023
Price gap 20% to 35% more than comparable steel The lower-cost option Western States (up to 20% to 30%); Englert (20% to 35%)
Service life 40 to 60 years 40 to 70 years inland Englert; Western States (aluminum)
Substrate warranty Not coating-dependent 25.5-year Galvalume substrate warranty; none within 1,500 ft of a coast Sheffield Metals
PVDF paint warranty 40 years film integrity, 30 years chalk and fade Same 40/30 terms on AZ50 Galvalume or G90 galvanized Sheffield COOLR warranty
Common residential thickness 0.027 to 0.034 in 24 gauge most common for standing seam; 22 to 29 gauge sold Sheffield Metals
Panel weight 0.032 in panel weighs under half of 24 ga Galvalume 24 ga Galvalume: 1 to 1.5 lb per sq ft finished Sheffield Metals
Thermal expansion 0.0000128 in per in per °F 0.0000065 in per in per °F Metal Sales
Dent resistance Softer, dents more easily (cosmetic) Harder, resists denting better Western States Metal Roofing
Best for Within 1 mile of the ocean, humid and salt-air sites Inland, budget, snow, wind, and hail zones Western States Metal Roofing

Which metal fits your roof: decision table

Run down the rows in order and stop at the first one that matches. Distances are measured from salt water, bays and salt marshes, which Sheffield Metals names alongside open surf as conditions Galvalume’s coating does not withstand.

If your situation is Choose Threshold and source
Home within 1,500 ft of a coast, bay or salt marsh Aluminum Sheffield offers no Galvalume paint or substrate warranty inside 1,500 ft
Home 1,500 ft to 1 mile from the ocean Aluminum, or get the steel maker’s coastal exclusion in writing Western States recommends avoiding steel within 1 mile of the ocean
Inland, budget is the deciding factor Galvalume steel, 24 or 26 gauge $5 to $13 vs $7 to $17 per sq ft installed (HomeGuide, Nov 2025)
Frequent hail, roof more than 1 mile inland 24 gauge steel Steel resists denting better (Western States); ask for the exact panel’s UL 2218 class in writing
Aluminum mechanically seamed panels longer than 15 to 20 ft Aluminum with expansion clips Sheffield recommends expansion clips per the project engineering above that length
Older or lightly framed roof where dead load matters Aluminum 0.032 in aluminum weighs under half of a 1 to 1.5 lb per sq ft 24 ga Galvalume panel (Sheffield)
Panels will touch copper, lead, treated lumber, concrete or brick Aluminum, or isolate steel from those materials Sheffield lists those materials as reactive with Galvalume

What is aluminum roofing?

Aluminum roofing is a lightweight metal roof, usually formed as standing seam panels or metal shingles, made from a soft alloy that resists corrosion without any coating. Its defining trait is that it does not red rust. Aluminum forms a thin, self-healing oxide layer, so a scratch or cut edge will not corrode the way exposed steel does (Sheffield Metals), which is why Englert names coastal homes, island developments, and tropical resort construction as its common uses.

Sheffield Metals lists 0.027 to 0.034 inch as the most common thickness for residential aluminum roofing, with 0.050 or 0.063 inch used for copings and caps. Because aluminum is more malleable than steel, it needs that extra thickness to reach comparable rigidity; Englert equates 0.032 to 0.050 inch aluminum to roughly 24 to 28 gauge steel, noting the comparison is approximate. The trade-off is that aluminum is a softer metal, so Western States notes it dents more readily from hail, falling branches, or foot traffic. Those dents are cosmetic and do not open a rust path, but they can be visible on flat panel areas.

What is steel roofing?

Steel roofing is a metal roof made from a steel core protected by a metallic coating, most often Galvalume (55% aluminum, 43.4% zinc, 1.6% silicon) or G90 galvanized zinc. The coating is what fends off rust, so steel’s corrosion resistance is only as good as that layer stays intact. Steel is harder and more rigid than aluminum, which is why it resists denting and handles high winds, heavy snow load, and hail well.

Englert lists 24 to 29 gauge as the residential range, and Sheffield names 24 gauge as the most common Galvalume thickness for standing seam; the lower the gauge number, the thicker the sheet. HomeGuide’s November 2025 range of $5 to $13 per sq ft installed for galvanized or Galvalume steel sits below aluminum’s $7 to $17. The weakness shows up wherever the coating is breached: a deep scratch, a cut panel edge, or a hail dent that cracks the finish exposes base steel to moisture. Salt spray speeds that process, which is why Sheffield does not warranty Galvalume within 1,500 feet of a coast.

Aluminum vs steel roofing: cost compared

Steel is the cheaper metal roof. HomeGuide’s metal roof cost guide (November 21, 2025) puts galvanized or Galvalume steel at $5 to $13 per square foot installed and aluminum at $700 to $1,700 per square ($7 to $17 per sq ft). On material alone, Western States lists standing seam aluminum at $4.50 to $6.50 per sq ft against $2.50 to $5.00 for steel. That upfront math also matters when weighing metal against asphalt, which our steel roof vs shingles cost guide breaks down over the long term.

Worked example: 2,000 sq ft roof (20 squares) Low end High end Source of rate
Galvanized or Galvalume steel, installed 20 x $500 = $10,000 20 x $1,300 = $26,000 HomeGuide, Nov 2025
Aluminum, installed 20 x $700 = $14,000 20 x $1,700 = $34,000 HomeGuide, Nov 2025
Aluminum premium $4,000 $8,000 Difference of the two rows

Material pricing on both metals also moves with commodity markets and trade policy. Import duties on steel and aluminum feed directly into coil and panel prices, which we track in the Metal Roofing Tariff and Import Exposure Report. Budget-driven inland projects usually land on Galvalume steel. Aluminum earns its premium inside the 1,500 ft to 1 mile coastal band, where the steel option may carry no substrate or paint warranty at all.

Which lasts longer, aluminum or steel?

Location decides this, not the metal alone. Englert puts steel roofs at 40 to 70 years when correctly installed and aluminum at 40 to 60 years, and Western States also quotes 40 to 60 years for aluminum. Near the coast the ranking flips. Aluminum can outlast steel there because it does not red rust, while a coated steel panel loses ground to salt-driven corrosion at every scratch and cut edge, the reason Sheffield excludes Galvalume within 1,500 feet of a coast from its 25.5-year substrate warranty.

Both metals can carry the same paint warranty. Sheffield’s 40-Year Limited COOLR PVDF warranty covers AZ50 Galvalume, G90 galvanized, and aluminum for 40 years against chipping, cracking, peeling, and flaking, with chalking and fading covered for 30 years. Reflective finishes also affect how hot the roof runs and how it ages, a factor we quantify in the Roofing Solar Reflectance and SRI Reference.

Durability, denting, and weather resistance

Steel resists denting; aluminum resists corrosion. That is the core durability trade-off described by both Western States and Englert. Steel’s higher hardness means it shrugs off hail and impact better, especially in thicker 24 gauge panels. Aluminum’s softness means visible dents are more likely, though those dents stay cosmetic and never turn into red rust.

  • Hail: Steel generally resists denting better. Western States notes that a thicker aluminum gauge improves strength but raises cost, so in hail country compare 0.032 and 0.040 inch quotes side by side, and ask for the UL 2218 impact class of the exact panel.
  • Salt air and humidity: Aluminum has the clear edge because it does not rely on a coating to avoid rust; Sheffield withholds Galvalume warranties inside 1,500 ft of a coast.
  • Wind and snow load: Steel’s rigidity gives it an advantage on large spans and heavy loads; for either metal, the panel’s tested uplift rating sets the clip spacing.
  • Coating breach: A scratch or cut edge is a non-issue for aluminum, but a potential rust starting point for steel.

For a fuller picture of how substrates and coatings combine, see our primer on what metal roofs are made of.

Installation differences that matter

Aluminum’s biggest install consideration is thermal movement. Metal Sales gives an expansion coefficient of 0.0000128 per °F for aluminum against 0.0000065 per °F for steel, so a 100 ft aluminum panel grows 1.56 inches over a 100°F swing while steel grows 0.78 inch. PAC-CLAD gives the same pattern for a 30 ft panel: about 7/16 inch for aluminum and about 1/4 inch for steel. Skip the floating clips and the panels can oil-can (show visible waviness) or warp.

Panel length Aluminum growth, 100°F swing Steel growth, 100°F swing
20 ft (240 in) 240 x 100 x 0.0000128 = 0.31 in 240 x 100 x 0.0000065 = 0.16 in
30 ft (360 in) 0.46 in 0.23 in
40 ft (480 in) 0.61 in 0.31 in

Formula from Metal Sales: change in length (in) = length (in) x temperature change (°F) x coefficient.

  1. Confirm the substrate and gauge: Match thickness to your climate: 24 gauge Galvalume for inland hail exposure, 0.032 inch or heavier aluminum near salt water.
  2. Plan for movement: On aluminum mechanically seamed panels longer than 15 to 20 ft, Sheffield recommends expansion clips per the applicable engineering.
  3. Protect cut edges on steel: Seal or hem cut edges so bare steel is not left exposed to moisture.
  4. Match fasteners to the metal: Use compatible screws and flashing to avoid galvanic corrosion between dissimilar metals; Sheffield Metals lists copper, lead, iron, treated lumber, concrete and brick as materials Galvalume should not touch. Gutters raise the same aluminum vs steel question, which our gutter materials comparison works through.

Panel profile also drives cost and labor. HomeGuide prices corrugated metal at $5 to $12 per sq ft installed against $9 to $16 for standing seam, on either metal. For the clip system itself, see concealed-clip standing seam, and our guide to corrugated metal panels covers sizes, gauges, and typical uses.

Pros and cons

Each metal trades one strength for another: aluminum buys corrosion immunity for a 20% to 35% premium and a softer surface, and steel buys hardness and lower cost at the risk of rust where its coating fails.

Aluminum Steel
Pros No red rust, under half the weight of 24 ga Galvalume, warrantable near the coast, recyclable Lower cost, harder and dent-resistant, rigid for wind and snow, widely available
Cons Costs 20% to 35% more, dents more easily, expands about twice as much, may oil-can Can rust where coating is breached, heavier, no Galvalume warranty within 1,500 ft of a coast

On sustainability the two are close. The Aluminum Association states that recycled aluminum saves 95% of the energy needed to make new aluminum, and Englert describes aluminum roofing as 100% recyclable. Steel is also highly recyclable, so both metals carry a strong end-of-life story compared with tear-off shingles. Zinc is a third premium option worth weighing, covered in our zinc roof guide, and a corrosion-resistant grade of steel is covered in our stainless steel roof guide.

Which should you choose?

Start with distance to salt water, then weigh budget and impact risk. The decision table above sets the thresholds; the short version is below.

  • You live within 1 mile of the ocean or a salt bay: Aluminum, because Western States recommends against steel inside 1 mile and Sheffield withholds Galvalume warranties inside 1,500 ft.
  • You are inland and budget-focused: Galvalume steel at $5 to $13 per sq ft installed (HomeGuide, Nov 2025).
  • You are in a heavy hail zone: Lean 24 gauge steel for dent resistance, or price 0.040 inch aluminum if corrosion resistance still matters more.
  • You want the lightest roof: 0.032 inch aluminum weighs under half of a 24 gauge Galvalume panel.
  • You face heavy snow load or high winds on long spans: Steel’s rigidity and half-as-large thermal movement are an advantage.

Distance from salt water decides most projects. More than a mile inland, steel’s lower cost and dent resistance make it the default. Inside that line, aluminum’s rust immunity and warrantability usually justify the $4,000 to $8,000 premium on a 20-square roof.

Aluminum vs steel roofing: frequently asked questions

Is aluminum or steel roofing better?

Neither is better in every case. Aluminum is better within about a mile of salt water because it never red rusts, and Western States Metal Roofing recommends it over steel inside that line. Steel is better inland because it costs less and resists denting from hail.

Is aluminum roofing more expensive than steel?

Yes. HomeGuide (November 2025) puts aluminum at $7 to $17 per square foot installed, versus $5 to $13 for galvanized or Galvalume steel. Manufacturers Western States and Englert put the aluminum premium at about 20% to 35% over comparable steel. The premium can be worth it in salt-air climates where steel corrodes faster.

Does aluminum roofing dent easily?

Aluminum is softer than steel, so it dents more easily from hail, falling branches, or foot traffic. Those dents are cosmetic and do not cause rust or shorten the roof’s life. Thicker aluminum resists denting better but costs more, so in hail-prone areas compare 0.032 and 0.040 inch quotes.

Which lasts longer, aluminum or steel roofing?

It depends on location. Englert puts steel at 40 to 70 years and aluminum at 40 to 60 years when correctly installed. Near the coast, aluminum can outlast steel because it does not rust, while steel slowly corrodes at any scratch or cut edge exposed to salt air.

Does steel roofing rust?

Steel roofing resists rust through a metallic coating, usually Galvalume or galvanized zinc. It can rust where that coating is breached, such as a deep scratch, a cut panel edge, or a hail dent that cracks the finish. Sheffield Metals does not offer Galvalume paint or substrate warranties within 1,500 feet of a coast for this reason.

Is aluminum roofing good for coastal areas?

Yes. Aluminum is one of the best metal roofing choices for coastal and high-humidity areas because it does not rust in salt air. It forms a self-healing oxide layer, so scratches and cut edges do not corrode. Western States Metal Roofing recommends aluminum instead of steel for projects within one mile of the ocean.