Metal roofing pros and cons come down to one trade: This Old House puts installed metal at an average $29 per square foot against $13 for asphalt shingles, and the extra money buys a 40+ year, non-combustible roof that sheds snow and can cut cooling load, at the price of storm noise and denting on softer panels.
By The Roofing Brief Team. Last reviewed: October 2026.
Metal roofing pros and cons at a glance
A metal roof wins on longevity, fire rating, wind-uplift testing, and cooling load, and loses on upfront cost (roughly $29 versus $13 per square foot for asphalt), storm noise, denting, and repair complexity.
| Pros of a metal roof | Cons of a metal roof |
|---|---|
| Lasts roughly 40 to 70+ years, two to three times a shingle roof | Costs about 2x to 3x asphalt shingles installed |
| Wind-uplift rated as a tested assembly (UL 580, UL 1897) and sheds snow and rain | Louder in heavy rain or hail without added underlayment or insulation |
| Non-combustible, commonly Class A fire rated as a system | Aluminum and copper dent from large hail or falling limbs |
| Reflects solar heat and can lower summer cooling load | Expansion and contraction can loosen fasteners or cause oil canning if installed poorly |
| Low maintenance, resists rot, mold, and insects | Repairs and color matching are harder than swapping a few shingles |
| Lightweight and often recyclable at end of life | Specialized install, fewer qualified crews, rarely a DIY job |
The main pros of a metal roof
The strongest case for a metal roof is 40+ years of service against 20 to 30 for asphalt, per This Old House, plus a Class A fire rating on tested assemblies and published wind-uplift ratings.
- Long lifespan. This Old House says metal roofs can last 40 years or more versus 20 to 30 for asphalt, and zinc up to 100 years; the 70-year figure applies to the better steel and aluminum standing seam systems.
- Severe-weather resistance. Wind resistance belongs to the tested assembly, not the metal: ask for the UL 580 or UL 1897 uplift report covering your exact panel, clip, and deck. Metal does not crack, warp, or rot, and it sheds snow and rain rather than absorbing it.
- Fire safety. Roof coverings are fire-tested under ASTM E108 (also published as UL 790), which grades them Class A, B, or C; Class A is the highest and many metal assemblies earn it, which matters in wildfire zones.
- Energy performance. A reflective or cool-rated finish cuts solar gain: a Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory cool roof fact sheet says a cool roof can reduce the annual air-conditioning energy use of a single-story building by up to 15%, and cool metal products are on its list.
- Low maintenance. Metal resists mold, mildew, rot, and insects, so upkeep is mostly periodic inspection of fasteners, sealant, and flashing rather than routine replacement.
- Light and recyclable. Metal panels weigh far less per square than tile or slate, and most are recyclable.
The main cons of a metal roof
The case against a metal roof is price and installation sensitivity: it costs $29 versus $13 per square foot for asphalt, soft metals dent, and thermal movement or poor fastening can loosen screws and cause visible waviness.
- Higher upfront cost. This Old House averages $29 per square foot for metal versus $13 for asphalt, so budget two to three times a shingle quote once steep pitch and trim are added (see the cost section below).
- Storm noise. Rain and hail sound louder on metal over open framing; solid decking, underlayment, and attic insulation quiet it.
- Denting. Aluminum and copper dent from large hail or falling branches; steel resists better, and stone-coated panels hide marks.
- Thermal movement. Metal expands and contracts with temperature swings, which loosens exposed screws on a wrong fastener layout. Oil canning (visible waviness) is, per McElroy Metal, an inherent characteristic of cold-rolled flat metal panels and not grounds for rejection.
- Repair complexity. One panel is harder to swap than a few shingles, and a weathered finish is hard to match years later.
- Installer scarcity. Metal is a specialized install with fewer qualified crews, and bad flashing or fastening is the usual leak source.
How much does a metal roof cost?
Installed metal roofing averages $29 per square foot in This Old House’s 2026 cost guide, or about $58,000 for a 2,000 square foot roof, against $13 per square foot for asphalt. By metal, the same guide lists zinc at $17, steel at $20, tin at $20, aluminum at $21, and copper at $35 per square foot (Homewyse data).
For standing seam only, This Old House’s standing seam cost guide (RSMeans data) lists steel at $4.59 to $8.55 per square foot, aluminum and zinc at $6.12 to $28.50, and copper at $12.24 to $26.60, which are material-driven ranges and run below the installed averages above. For a full breakdown of what drives the number, see our roof replacement cost guide.
How long does a metal roof last?
A metal roof usually lasts 40 to 70 years, against 20 to 30 for asphalt per This Old House. Service life depends on the coating, the fastening system, and the installer as much as the metal. Our roof lifespan by material report compares expected service life across every common roofing material.
Steel and aluminum standing seam systems commonly reach 50 years or more when detailed correctly. Exposed-fastener panels need screw and gasket service sooner because the fasteners weather faster than the panel. Zinc is rated up to 100 years by This Old House.
Steel vs tin vs aluminum: which metal roof?
The pros and cons of a steel roof, a tin roof, and an aluminum roof differ on cost, corrosion, and dent resistance: steel is the lowest-cost common choice ($20 per square foot installed per This Old House, against $21 for aluminum), aluminum resists salt air, and a modern “tin roof” is usually steel or terne-coated steel.
| Metal | Typical installed cost | Lifespan | Best for | Watch-outs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Steel (galvanized/Galvalume) | Lowest metal cost; $4.59 to $8.55 per sq ft standing seam (This Old House, RSMeans) | 40 to 70 years | Most homes seeking value and strength | Needs coating to resist rust; can dent under severe hail |
| Aluminum | $6.12 to $28.50 per sq ft standing seam (This Old House, RSMeans) | 40 to 70 years | Coastal and salt-air climates | Softer, dents more easily than steel |
| Tin / terne-coated steel | Roughly $5 to $12 per sq ft per Angi | Often 20 to 40 years with upkeep | Historic and specialty restorations | Needs periodic painting; true tin is rare today |
Related: aluminum vs steel roofing, standing seam vs corrugated metal roof, and the best metal roofing for homes.
Is a metal roof worth it?
A metal roof is usually worth it if you will own the home past year 20 to 25, when the cost per year of service falls below a 20 to 30 year shingle roof, or you live where fire, hail, wind, or snow are real risks. It is harder to justify if you expect to move within a few years or your budget rules out the two-to-three-times premium over shingles.
- Estimate how long you will own the home. At $29 per square foot over 40 years versus $13 over 20 to 30 years, the annual cost gap narrows the longer you stay.
- Weigh your climate risk. Wildfire, hurricane, hail, and heavy-snow regions get the most value from metal’s fire rating, wind rating, and shedding ability.
- Get at least two installed quotes for metal and for architectural shingles, then compare cost per expected year of life, not just sticker price.
- Confirm the crew installs your exact system and check the material and workmanship warranty terms before signing.
- Ask your insurer whether a Class A metal roof affects your premium or eligibility, since this varies by carrier and state.
Frequently asked questions
Are metal roofs noisy when it rains?
Metal roofs are louder only over open framing, as on a barn. Over solid decking with underlayment and attic insulation, the sound is dampened.
Do metal roofs attract lightning?
No. The National Weather Service says the presence of metal makes no difference to where lightning strikes; height, pointy shape, and isolation decide that. Metal is non-combustible, so a strike will not ignite the roof covering.
Do metal roofs make a house hotter?
A metal roof does not make a house hotter, and a cool-rated finish can lower cooling load. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory says a cool roof can cut a single-story building’s annual air-conditioning energy use by up to 15%; dark uncoated panels with no ventilation gain less.
Do metal roofs rust?
Steel panels resist rust through a zinc or Galvalume coating (about 55% aluminum, 43.5% zinc, 1.5% silicon, per Englert) plus a factory paint finish, and aluminum does not rust. Rust starts where the coating is scratched to bare steel or at cut edges, so aluminum is the safer pick in salt air.
Is a metal roof worth the extra cost?
A metal roof can be worth the extra cost if you keep the home past year 20 to 25 or live in a high fire, wind, hail, or snow area, because a 40 to 70 year life spreads the price over more years than a 20 to 30 year shingle roof. If you expect to move within a few years, shingles usually make more financial sense.
Can you put a metal roof over shingles?
Often yes over one layer. IRC R908.3.1.1 bars a roof recover where the existing roof has two or more applications of roof covering, or is water-soaked or deteriorated, and your local code and the panel maker’s warranty can be stricter.