Subscribe

MATERIALS · July 28, 2026

Cedar Shake vs Asphalt Shingles: Cost, Lifespan, Fire

Cedar shake vs asphalt shingles: $25 to $30 vs $5 to $8 per sq ft installed, 30 to 50 vs 15 to 20+ year life, unrated vs Class A fire. Sourced, 2026.

By The Roofing Brief Team. Last reviewed: October 2026.

Cedar shake vs asphalt shingles comes down to a trade between look and cost of ownership: real cedar shake runs $25 to $30 per square foot installed per HomeGuide’s cedar shake cost guide (November 2025), while architectural asphalt runs about $5 to $8 per square foot in our 2026 Roofing Cost Report. Asphalt is a Class A roof covering out of the box, while untreated wood shakes carry no fire rating at all. For most homes, asphalt wins on price and insurability; cedar wins when the architecture, the budget and the insurer all support it.

On a 2,000 square foot roof that works out to about $10,000 to $16,000 for architectural asphalt versus $50,000 to $60,000 for real cedar shake in HomeGuide’s calculator, which includes tear-off. Synthetic cedar shake lands in between at $24,000 to $40,000 for the same roof ($12 to $20 per square foot, same HomeGuide guide). That gap, plus how insurers now treat wood roofs, drives most of the decision below.

Cedar shake vs asphalt shingles at a glance

Real cedar shake costs roughly 3 to 6 times as much per square foot as architectural asphalt ($25 to $30 versus $5 to $8 installed), needs cleaning and a preservative treatment every 3 to 5 years per HomeGuide, and is unrated for fire unless it is pressure treated. Asphalt architectural shingles are the budget default: Class A fire rated, wind rated under ASTM D7158, and accepted by insurers. The table sums up how they differ on the points that decide the job.

Factor Cedar shake Asphalt shingles (architectural) Source
Material Split or sawn western red cedar (Certi-Split, Certi-Sawn grades) Fiberglass mat, asphalt, mineral granules (ASTM D3462) Cedar Shake and Shingle Bureau; IRC R905.2.4
Installed cost per sq ft $25 to $30 (real); $12 to $20 (synthetic) $5 to $8 HomeGuide, Nov 2025; TRB 2026 Roofing Cost Report
2,000 sq ft roof $50,000 to $60,000 (real); $24,000 to $40,000 (synthetic) $10,000 to $16,000 Same sources
Lifespan 30 to 50 years with maintenance 15 to 20+ years HomeGuide comparison table, Nov 2025
Fire rating Unrated untreated; Class B or C with Certi-Guard treatment; Class A only as a tested assembly Class A (ASTM E108 / UL 790) IBHS/RICOWI cedar guide; CSSB Certi-Guard sheet
Minimum roof slope 3:12 (IRC R905.8.2) 2:12, with double underlayment from 2:12 to 4:12 (IRC R905.2.2) 2021 IRC Chapter 9
Wind rating No IRC wind class requirement; two fasteners per shake (IRC R905.8.6) ASTM D7158 Class D, G or H by design wind speed (IRC Table R905.2.4.1) 2021 IRC Chapter 9
Maintenance Inspection yearly; preservative every 3 to 5 years ($500 to $1,500) Annual inspection HomeGuide, Nov 2025
Best for Craftsman, Cape Cod and historic homes outside wildfire zones Most homes, tight budgets, wildfire-exposed lots Editorial

What is a cedar shake roof?

A cedar shake roof is made from thick wedges of western red cedar. The Cedar Shake and Shingle Bureau grades three main shake types: Certi-Split Handsplit and Resawn (one split face, one sawn face), Certi-Split Straight-Split (split on both faces) and Certi-Sawn Tapersawn (sawn on both faces, heavier than a shingle). Shakes carry a thicker butt than sawn cedar shingles, which sets their exposure, the felt interlay between courses and the weight per square. HomeGuide prices shakes at $2 to $5 per square foot more than cedar shingles.

Under the 2021 IRC, shakes go on slopes of 3:12 or steeper (R905.8.2), with 18 inch strips of No. 30 felt interlaid between courses (R905.8.7) and a maximum exposure of 7 1/2 inches for 18 inch No. 1 shakes and 10 inches for 24 inch No. 1 shakes (Table R905.8.6). Humid or heavily shaded sites grow moss and rot faster, so the upkeep schedule matters; see our guide to cedar shake roof maintenance for what that involves. When damage does set in, our guide to cedar shake roof repair covers fixes and cost.

What are asphalt shingles?

Asphalt shingles are a fiberglass mat saturated with asphalt and surfaced with mineral granules, made to ASTM D3462 per IRC section R905.2.4. Architectural (dimensional) shingles are thicker and more textured than three-tab, and the IRC requires a wind class matched to the site: ASTM D7158 Class G or H where the ultimate design wind speed is 129 mph or more, and Class H at 168 mph or more (Table R905.2.4.1). Asphalt also sits on lower slopes than cedar: 2:12 minimum, with double underlayment between 2:12 and 4:12 (R905.2.2).

The tradeoff is a flatter look and a shorter life, 15 to 20+ years in HomeGuide’s material comparison. Designer lines narrow the look gap; for a wood look in asphalt, see our review of shake-look asphalt shingles like CertainTeed Presidential. A builder-grade three-tab and a heavy laminated designer line differ in weight, wind class and warranty, so compare the data sheets of the exact lines a contractor quotes.

Cost: cedar shake vs asphalt shingles

Architectural asphalt runs about $5 to $8 per square foot installed in our 2026 Roofing Cost Report, or $10,000 to $16,000 on 2,000 square feet of roof. HomeGuide puts real cedar shake at $25 to $30 per square foot, or $50,000 to $60,000 on the same roof, by grade: common grade $20 to $25, select grade $25 to $30 and 100% straight grain $30 to $35. Labor is 40% to 60% of a cedar job in HomeGuide’s breakdown, and cedar crews are slower and more specialized.

Lifecycle cost widens the gap further. HomeGuide lists periodic wood treatments at $500 to $1,500 every 3 to 5 years, roof cleaning at $250 to $600 and an annual inspection at $100 to $400, costs an asphalt roof mostly skips. Steep roofs add 10% to 20% to labor and two-story homes 15% to 25%, per the same guide. The worked example below uses a 2,000 square foot roof over a 40 year horizon; treat it as planning math, not a quote.

Cost element (2,000 sq ft roof) Real cedar shake Synthetic shake Architectural asphalt Source
Upfront install, incl. tear-off $50,000 to $60,000 $24,000 to $40,000 $10,000 to $16,000 HomeGuide Nov 2025; TRB 2026 Cost Report
Treatment every 3 to 5 years $500 to $1,500 each None required None HomeGuide Nov 2025
Treatments over 40 years 8 to 13 cycles, about $4,000 to $19,500 $0 $0 Our arithmetic from HomeGuide figures
Expected life 30 to 50 years 40 to 60 years 15 to 20+ years HomeGuide Nov 2025
Replacements in 40 years 0 to 1 0 1 to 2 Our arithmetic from the lifespans
Insurance effect Not Class A untreated; no CA wildfire roof discount Class A on rated lines Class A; qualifies for CA roof discount California Department of Insurance

For how roof material and age move premiums, see our report on homeowners insurance premiums by roof type and age.

Synthetic cedar shake vs asphalt: cost and specs

Synthetic cedar shake costs $12 to $20 per square foot installed per HomeGuide, about 1.5 to 4 times architectural asphalt at $5 to $8, and about 40% to 80% of real cedar’s $25 to $30. Composite lines are tested like other roof coverings: DaVinci Multi-Width Shake lists a Class A fire rating, a Class 4 impact rating and a Lifetime Limited Material Warranty with a 10 year non-prorated period, per Westlake Royal’s product page. HomeGuide lists synthetic shake life at 40 to 60 years.

For a cedar look without the treatment cycle, synthetic shake beats real cedar on upfront price ($24,000 to $40,000 vs $50,000 to $60,000 on 2,000 sq ft) and skips the $500 to $1,500 treatments; for the lowest total cost, asphalt still wins. Our guide to synthetic cedar shake roofing compares the composite brands line by line.

Lifespan and durability

HomeGuide lists real cedar shake at 30 to 50 years with proper maintenance and asphalt shingles at 15 to 20+ years. The IBHS and RICOWI cedar roof guide ties cedar life to wood grade, installation, maintenance, foot traffic and overhanging trees, and notes some curling, cupping and splitting is normal aging. Neglected cedar in a wet, shaded location can fail well before an asphalt roof would.

On wind, the code treats the two differently. Asphalt shingles carry a tested ASTM D7158 or D3161 wind class printed on the bundle (IRC R905.2.4.1). Shakes rely on fastening: two fasteners per shake, stainless steel Type 304 or 316 or hot-dipped nails, and Type 316 stainless within 15 miles of saltwater (IRC R905.8.6). The IBHS guide says wind damage on cedar usually shows as fastener pull-through or dislodged fasteners rather than a mark on the wood. For a wider material comparison, see our types of roofing materials guide.

Fire rating and the insurance problem

Untreated cedar shake has no fire class at all. The IBHS and RICOWI guide states that untreated shakes and shingles are “unrated, meaning they do not meet the requirements for Class C,” while asphalt shingles test to Class A under ASTM E108 / UL 790, the highest of the three classes. Pressure-treated cedar sold under the CSSB Certi-Guard label reaches Class B (red label) or Class C (blue label), and Class A only as a tested component system with added underlayers. IRC R902.2 requires fire-retardant shakes to be treated by the full-cell vacuum-pressure process under AWPA C1, with each bundle labeled.

The practical fallout is insurance. The California Department of Insurance Safer from Wildfires program lists a Class A roof as a discount-qualifying step, names asphalt shingles, concrete tile and metal as qualifying, and states that wood shake shingles are not Class A rated. IRC R902.1 also requires Class A, B or C roofing wherever local law designates it or where the roof edge is within 3 feet of a lot line. Ask your carrier two questions before choosing cedar: is a wood roof surcharged or non-renewable on this policy, and does a Class B Certi-Guard roof change that answer. Our wildfire roof risk report covers where Class A roofs are effectively mandatory.

Maintenance and upkeep

HomeGuide’s schedule for cedar is an annual inspection ($100 to $400), debris and moss removal, and a wood preservative every 3 to 5 years ($500 to $1,500). The IBHS guide warns that high-pressure washing by inexperienced crews causes significant damage and that garden hose pressure clears most debris. Asphalt asks only for an annual visual check, clean gutters and prompt repair of lifted or missing tabs.

If the cedar look is the goal without the upkeep, a synthetic shake such as DaVinci Multi-Width Shake needs no preservative cycle and carries a Class A fire rating. See synthetic cedar shake roofing for how those compare on cost and performance.

Pros and cons

Cedar leads on looks and potential longevity; asphalt leads on cost, fire rating and low maintenance.

Cedar shake pros:

  • Natural wood texture and deep shadow lines that suit historic and Craftsman homes
  • 30 to 50 year potential lifespan when maintained (HomeGuide)
  • Cedar’s natural oils resist rot and insects
  • Can install over spaced 1×4 sheathing boards as well as solid decks (IRC R905.8.1)

Cedar shake cons:

  • About 3 to 6 times the per square foot cost of architectural asphalt
  • Unrated for fire untreated; Certi-Guard treatment reaches Class B or C
  • Preservative every 3 to 5 years at $500 to $1,500
  • Not Class A for California’s wildfire insurance discount

Asphalt shingle pros:

  • Lowest upfront cost of common steep-slope roofs at $5 to $8 per square foot
  • Class A fire rating as standard
  • Tested wind class (ASTM D7158) printed on every bundle
  • Installs down to 2:12 slope

Asphalt shingle cons:

  • Shorter 15 to 20+ year life in HomeGuide’s comparison
  • Flatter, less distinctive appearance
  • Ages faster under intense heat and UV
  • Can lift or tear in high wind once the seal strip fails

Which should you choose?

Choose asphalt shingles if budget, insurability or fire risk lead your decision. Choose cedar shake if the architecture calls for a wood roof, the budget absorbs a $50,000 to $60,000 job on a 2,000 square foot roof plus treatment every 3 to 5 years, and your insurer will write it. The table sets the thresholds.

If your situation is Choose Why
Roof budget under about $25,000 for 2,000 sq ft Architectural asphalt Real cedar starts near $50,000 at HomeGuide’s $25 per sq ft floor
Wildfire zone, or roof edge within 3 ft of a lot line Asphalt or Class A synthetic Untreated cedar is unrated; IRC R902.1 requires a rated covering there
California home seeking the Safer from Wildfires discount Any Class A covering CDI states wood shake is not Class A
Roof slope between 2:12 and 3:12 Asphalt with double underlayment Wood shakes need 3:12 minimum (IRC R905.8.2)
Want the cedar look, budget $24,000 to $40,000 Synthetic shake $12 to $20 per sq ft, no preservative cycle
Historic district requires real wood, insurer approves Certi-Guard treated cedar Class B or C label; ask about a Class A component system
You will not treat the roof every 3 to 5 years Asphalt or synthetic Cedar’s 30 to 50 year life assumes maintenance
  1. Set the budget ceiling. Price real cedar at $25 to $30 per square foot and asphalt at $5 to $8; if the cedar figure for your roof size is out of reach, the decision is made.
  2. Check the fire and insurance picture. In a wildfire-exposed area, within 3 feet of a lot line (IRC R902.1), or if your carrier surcharges wood roofs, asphalt or a Class A synthetic is the safer path.
  3. Measure the slope. Under 3:12, shakes are not permitted by IRC R905.8.2; asphalt works down to 2:12.
  4. Be honest about maintenance. If you will not clean and treat on a 3 to 5 year cycle, cedar’s lifespan advantage disappears.
  5. Match the architecture. Craftsman, Cape Cod, Tudor and historic homes justify cedar’s look; most other styles do fine on architectural asphalt or a synthetic shake.

Frequently asked questions

Is cedar shake better than asphalt shingles?

Neither wins on every count. Real cedar shake lasts 30 to 50 years with maintenance per HomeGuide and has a natural wood look, but it costs $25 to $30 per square foot installed versus $5 to $8 for architectural asphalt, and untreated cedar has no fire rating. Asphalt is Class A fire rated and accepted by insurers, so it is the practical pick for most budgets and for wildfire-exposed homes.

How much more does a cedar shake roof cost than asphalt?

About 3 to 6 times as much per square foot. On a 2,000 square foot roof, HomeGuide (November 2025) puts real cedar shake at $50,000 to $60,000 including tear-off, while architectural asphalt runs about $10,000 to $16,000 at $5 to $8 per square foot in The Roofing Brief’s 2026 Roofing Cost Report. Cedar also needs a preservative treatment every 3 to 5 years at $500 to $1,500 each.

What does synthetic cedar shake cost vs asphalt?

Synthetic cedar shake costs $12 to $20 per square foot installed per HomeGuide, or $24,000 to $40,000 on a 2,000 square foot roof, against $10,000 to $16,000 for architectural asphalt. That is about 1.5 to 4 times the asphalt price, in exchange for the shake look, no preservative cycle and, on lines such as DaVinci Multi-Width Shake, a Class A fire and Class 4 impact rating.

How long does each roof last?

HomeGuide lists real cedar shake at 30 to 50 years with proper maintenance, synthetic shake at 40 to 60 years and asphalt shingles at 15 to 20+ years. Cedar’s longer life depends on cleaning, a preservative every 3 to 5 years and a site that dries out; neglected cedar under trees can fail sooner than asphalt.

Are cedar shake roofs a fire risk?

Untreated cedar shakes and shingles are unrated, meaning they do not meet Class C, per the IBHS and RICOWI cedar roof guide, while asphalt shingles are Class A. Pressure-treated Certi-Guard cedar reaches Class B (red label) or Class C (blue label), and Class A only as a tested component system. California’s Department of Insurance states wood shake is not Class A rated.

Do insurers cover cedar shake roofs?

Many do, but wood roofs lose ground on price. California’s Safer from Wildfires regulation gives a discount for a Class A roof, and the Department of Insurance states wood shake does not qualify. Ask your carrier whether a wood roof is surcharged or non-renewable on your policy and whether a Class B Certi-Guard roof changes the answer before you sign a cedar contract.

Is there a lower-maintenance way to get the cedar look?

Yes. Synthetic or composite shakes copy cedar’s texture without the 3 to 5 year preservative cycle. DaVinci Multi-Width Shake, for example, lists Class A fire, Class 4 impact and a Lifetime Limited Material Warranty with a 10 year non-prorated period. Expect $12 to $20 per square foot installed per HomeGuide, above asphalt but below real cedar.