Subscribe

INDUSTRY REPORTS · July 23, 2026

Roofing Franchise vs Independent Report (2026): Which Roofers Make More

Roofing franchise vs independent: FDD fees of 7% to 15% of revenue cost $140,000 to $300,000 a year at $2M in sales. Break-even math inside.

In the roofing franchise vs independent comparison, independent roofers keep more of every dollar, but a franchise can help a new owner reach revenue faster and fail less often. Across 2023 to 2026 Franchise Disclosure Documents (FDDs), named roofing franchises charge 7% to 15% of gross revenue in ongoing fees (royalty plus brand fund). At $2 million in annual sales, that is roughly $140,000 to $300,000 handed to the franchisor every year, or about $700,000 to $1.5 million over five years. An independent keeps that money but pays for its own brand, lead generation, and systems. The tables below put the FDD numbers side by side with the break-even math.

Key findings

  • Ongoing franchisor fees run 7% to 15% of gross revenue across the full-service roofing franchises reviewed here (royalty plus national brand fund), per their 2023 to 2026 FDDs.
  • At $2 million in revenue, franchise fees cost about $140,000 to $300,000 per year, or roughly $700,000 to $1.5 million over a five-year term.
  • Opening a full-service roofing franchise costs about $172,000 to $466,000 in total initial investment (FDD Item 7), including franchise fees of $35,000 to $70,000.
  • Average unit revenue, where disclosed in Item 19, was about $4.18 million for Bumble Roofing (2023 FDD), $3.39 million for Honest Abe Roofing (2023 FDD), and $2.14 million average for Storm Guard.
  • Independent roofers net 5% to 15% and keep the royalty, but self-fund brand and lead generation, where roofing customer acquisition cost runs near $228 per lead.
  • Roofing specialty contractors failed at about 39% over five years (JCHS analysis of the 2007 to 2012 cohort), lower than general remodelers near 51%.

The short answer: who makes more, a franchise or an independent roofer?

On margin, the independent wins because it keeps the 7% to 15% that a franchisee pays to the brand. On speed and survival, the franchise often wins because national systems, financing, and a recognized name can lift close rates and shorten the ramp. The model that earns more depends on one question: does the brand add more revenue or margin than its fees subtract? Below that break-even, the independent keeps more; above it, the franchise does.

The comparison is not franchise owner pay versus independent owner pay in the abstract. Reported franchise owner profit often lands near $75,000 to $150,000, while established independent owners commonly report $100,000 to $300,000, and large commercial independents can exceed $1 million (industry compensation ranges, 2026). Those bands overlap heavily, so the deciding factor is fee load against brand value, not a single headline number.

What roofing franchises actually charge (FDD fee table)

Every US franchisor must provide a Franchise Disclosure Document under the FTC Franchise Rule (16 CFR Part 436). Item 5 and Item 6 list the initial fee and ongoing fees, Item 7 lists total investment, and Item 19 lists financial performance where the franchisor chooses to disclose it. The table below ranks the full-service roofing franchises from the lowest to the highest ongoing fee load (Roof Maxx last, for context), using their most recent public FDD summaries.

Franchise Initial franchise fee Royalty Brand / ad fund Total ongoing fee load Total initial investment (Item 7)
Honest Abe Roofing $35,000 to $70,000 5% 2% ~7% $185,000 to $466,000
Storm Guard $65,000 6.25% 0.75% ~7% $200,400 to $236,600
Bumble Roofing $49,500 6.5% (tiered down to 4.5%) 1% to 2% national* ~8% $171,998 to $313,834
Mighty Dog Roofing $59,500 8.5% 5% to 8% ~15% $184,000 to $236,000
Roof Maxx (rejuvenation)** ~$25,000 to $45,000 ~10% varies ~10% $49,700 to $119,500

*Bumble Roofing also requires local advertising of 5% of gross revenue or $3,500 per month, whichever is higher. That is marketing spend an independent would also incur, so it is excluded from the franchisor-fee figure above. **Roof Maxx sells a roof-rejuvenation treatment, not full replacement, with a much smaller ticket (about $1,200 to $2,200), so it is shown for context but is not directly comparable to full-service replacement franchises. All figures from company FDD summaries and franchise-review databases, 2023 to 2026; verify against the current FDD before relying on any number.

The royalty drag: what franchise fees cost over five years

The royalty drag is the cash a franchisee pays the franchisor that an independent keeps: fee load times revenue, so a 7% load costs $70,000 at $1M and $210,000 at $3M. Success makes the drag larger, not smaller.

Franchise Ongoing fee load At $1M revenue At $2M revenue At $3M revenue 5-year drag at $2M
Honest Abe / Storm Guard ~7% $70,000 $140,000 $210,000 ~$700,000
Bumble Roofing ~8% $80,000 $160,000 $240,000 ~$800,000
Mighty Dog Roofing ~15% $150,000 $300,000 $450,000 ~$1,500,000

The Roofing Brief calculation above multiplies each brand’s stated fee load by revenue; it is arithmetic, not an FDD figure. The gap between the lightest and heaviest fee structures is wide. A Mighty Dog franchisee at $2 million pays about $160,000 per year more than a Honest Abe franchisee at the same revenue, purely on fee structure. Over a typical multi-year term, that difference alone can exceed the entire initial investment.

What franchise revenue looks like (Item 19)

Where a franchisor discloses Item 19, average unit revenue for roofing brands sits in the low millions, well above a typical first-year independent. These are averages across reporting units and include strong performers, so they overstate what a new single-territory owner is likely to see in year one.

Franchise Average unit revenue Source / note
Bumble Roofing ~$4.18 million 2023 FDD Item 19 (all reporting units)
Honest Abe Roofing ~$3.39 million (top unit ~$10.6M) 2023 FDD Item 19
Storm Guard ~$2.14 million average Franchise-review summary of FDD
Mighty Dog Roofing ~$1.9 million (estimate) External estimate; FDD reportedly does not disclose AUV

Item 19 is not a promise. Individual results vary widely by market, storm activity, and operator skill, and past averages do not predict a specific franchisee’s outcome. Read the full Item 19 table, including the share of units that met or beat the average, before weighting any single figure.

What independents keep, and what they pay for instead

An independent roofer keeps the full 7% to 15% a franchisee would surrender, but spends it, and more, building what a franchise supplies out of the box. Independent net margins run 5% to 15%, with well-run shops hitting 12% to 15% on 30% to 40% gross margins (roofing P&L benchmarks, 2026). On $2 million in revenue, that is roughly $100,000 to $300,000 in net profit before owner salary decisions.

The catch is what the royalty would have bought. An independent funds its own brand awareness, lead generation, sales training, estimating software, and financing relationships. Roofing customer acquisition is expensive: cost per lead has run near $228 in the roofing and gutters category, among the highest of any home service. A brand that reliably lowers that number, or lifts close rates, can be worth its fee. One that does not is pure drag.

Break-even: when does a roofing franchise pay for itself?

A roofing franchise pays for itself only when its brand and systems add more gross profit than the fee load removes. If the ongoing fee load is 7%, the brand has to lift revenue or margin by more than 7% versus what the same owner would achieve independently. The break-even test runs in four steps.

  1. Set the fee load. Take royalty plus national brand fund from Item 6. Call it F (for example, 7% or 15%).
  2. Estimate the brand lift. Judge how much the name, leads, and systems raise revenue or gross margin over your independent baseline. Close-rate gains matter most: at roughly $228 per roofing lead, lifting a 20% close rate to 25% would cut cost per sale from $1,140 to $912 (illustrative arithmetic, not a measured result).
  3. Compare lift to fee. If brand lift exceeds F, the franchise nets more. If it falls short, the independent nets more. A 15% fee load needs a large, durable lift to clear.
  4. Add the ramp and survival value. Credit the franchise for faster year-one revenue and lower failure odds against the roofing baseline of about 39% five-year failure (JCHS), then discount for the multi-year commitment and reduced flexibility.

This is why a 7% brand can be a reasonable trade while a 15% brand faces a steep bar. At 15%, the brand must lift revenue by about 18% (15 divided by 85) every year just to leave the owner with the same dollars as going independent, before any margin effect.

Survival: do franchise roofers fail less often?

Roofing is already one of the more durable trades. In the Joint Center for Housing Studies analysis of the 2007 to 2012 cohort, roofing specialty contractors failed at about 39% over five years, better than general remodelers near 51%, and specialty trades overall ranged from 33% (plumbing and HVAC) to 39% (roofing). Across all US businesses, roughly 49% fail within five years (BLS, 2024).

Franchising is often credited with higher survival, and industry sources cite franchise five-year success rates of 75% or more. Those figures come from franchise advocacy and older business literature rather than a clean BLS franchise-versus-independent construction study, so treat them as directional. The defensible read: a good franchise can reduce the operational mistakes that sink new roofers, but it does not remove market, weather, or cash-flow risk, and a weak franchise can add fee pressure that raises failure odds.

Which model fits which owner?

  • Lean toward a franchise if you are new to roofing and would rather pay 7% to 15% of revenue (the Item 6 range above) for a proven sales and estimating system, financing and supplier relationships, and a faster, lower-variance start.
  • Lean toward independent if you already have roofing or trade experience and a referral base, and can fund your own lead engine at roughly $228 per lead while holding the 12% to 15% net margins that well-run shops report.
  • Run the numbers either way. Pull the actual FDD Item 6, 7, and 19, model the royalty drag at your target revenue, and compare it against what you would realistically spend building the same capabilities alone.

Decision table: if X, then Y

If you Then
Have never run a roofing company and want the lowest fee load Compare Honest Abe and Storm Guard (~7% ongoing fee load) before Mighty Dog (~15%).
Expect to reach $2 million in sales Budget a royalty drag of $140,000 (7%) to $300,000 (15%) per year, or $700,000 to $1.5 million over five years.
Can only fund a smaller start Check Item 7: full-service roofing franchises run $172,000 to $466,000; Roof Maxx sells a different, smaller rejuvenation service at $49,700 to $119,500.
Already have a referral base and trade experience Model independence first: 5% to 15% net margins with no royalty, minus your own lead cost near $228 per lead.

Methodology and sources

Fee, investment, and Item 19 figures are drawn from company Franchise Disclosure Document summaries and franchise-review databases published between 2023 and 2026 (Franchise Chatter, Franchise Payback, Sharpsheets, and franchisor materials). Ongoing fee load combines royalty and national brand or ad fund only; local advertising minimums are excluded because independents incur similar marketing costs. The royalty-drag figures are The Roofing Brief’s own arithmetic, multiplying each stated fee load by revenue, and are not FDD disclosures. Margin and owner-pay bands come from 2026 roofing profit benchmarks (Roofr, Profitability Partners, industry advisors). Survival figures come from the Joint Center for Housing Studies (2007 to 2012 remodeling cohort) and BLS business survival data (2024). FDD figures change annually and vary by territory; anyone evaluating a specific franchise should verify every number against the current FDD and consult a franchise attorney before signing.

For the wider market context behind these numbers, see The Roofing Brief’s US roofing industry concentration report and our ranking of the best states to start a roofing company. To weigh roofing against alternatives, compare our roofing versus other skilled trades analysis, and to size the lead-generation costs an independent must fund, see the roofing cost per lead benchmark.

Reviewed by The Roofing Brief Team. Last reviewed: October 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Do roofing franchise owners make more than independents?

Not automatically. Independents keep the 7% to 15% of gross revenue that a franchisee pays the franchisor, so on pure margin they keep more. A franchise earns more only when its brand, leads, and systems add more revenue or gross profit than its fee load removes. Established independent owners often report $100,000 to $300,000, while franchise owners commonly report $75,000 to $150,000, though the bands overlap widely.

How much does a roofing franchise cost to start?

Total initial investment for a full-service roofing franchise runs about $172,000 to $466,000 per FDD Item 7, including an initial franchise fee of roughly $35,000 to $70,000. Lower-cost roof-rejuvenation models like Roof Maxx start near $49,700 to $119,500. Actual ranges vary by territory and buildout, so confirm the figure in the current Item 7.

What royalty do roofing franchises charge?

Royalties on named roofing franchises run about 5% to 8.5% of gross revenue, plus a national brand or ad fund of roughly 0.75% to 8%. Combined ongoing fee loads range from about 7% (Honest Abe, Storm Guard) to about 15% (Mighty Dog). Some brands tier the royalty down as revenue rises. Local advertising minimums are separate from these franchisor fees.

Which roofing franchise makes the most money?

By disclosed average unit revenue, Bumble Roofing reported about $4.18 million and Honest Abe Roofing about $3.39 million in their 2023 FDD Item 19 tables, with Storm Guard near $2.14 million. These are averages across all reporting units and include top performers, so a new single-territory owner should expect less, especially in year one. Item 19 averages do not predict an individual result.

What is the failure rate of roofing businesses?

Roofing specialty contractors failed at about 39% over five years in the Joint Center for Housing Studies analysis of the 2007 to 2012 cohort, better than general remodelers near 51%. Across all US businesses, roughly 49% fail within five years per BLS 2024 data. Roofing is therefore one of the more durable trades, though weather, cash flow, and market risk still apply to franchise and independent alike.

Is a roofing franchise worth it?

A roofing franchise can be worth it for a newer owner who values a proven sales system, financing, and a recognized brand, and who accepts trading 7% to 15% of revenue for a faster, lower-variance start. It is less compelling for experienced roofers with a local reputation and their own lead engine. Run the break-even test: the brand must add more gross profit than its fee load subtracts.