Subscribe

MATERIALS · July 11, 2026

Shake Style Metal Roofing: Cost, Brands, vs Cedar

Metal shake roofing costs $6 to $14 per sq ft installed vs $25 to $30 for real cedar. DECRA, Classic, Interlock, ProVia and PINE-CREST specs compared.

By The Roofing Brief Team. Last reviewed: October 2026.

Shake style metal roofing, also sold as metal shake roofing, is steel or aluminum formed and finished to imitate hand-split cedar shakes, giving the deep, three-dimensional wood look without the rot or insect damage of real cedar. Panels carry stamped shadow lines, varied shake heights, and rustic color blends. HomeGuide puts metal shingles at $6 to $14 per square foot installed, against $25 to $30 for real cedar shake, and the shake lines below carry 50-year to lifetime limited warranties.

Weights run from 46 lb per square for Classic Metal Roofing Systems’ .019 in. aluminum Country Manor Shake to 150 lb per square for stone-coated steel DECRA Shake XD, and IRC R905.4.2 sets a 3:12 minimum slope for any metal roof shingle.

What is shake style metal roofing?

Shake style metal roofing is a panel or interlocking-shingle system pressed from steel or aluminum to reproduce the irregular, split-grain texture of a cedar shake roof. Manufacturers stamp several individual shakes into each panel at different heights and widths: Classic Metal Roofing Systems forms each Country Manor Shake panel to look like eight shakes of varying height, width and thickness. A multi-tone finish or stone coating then makes the surface read as weathered wood from the ground.

The category is sometimes sold as metal shake, metal cedar shake, or steel roofing tiles; Westlake Royal sells its version as Unified Steel PINE-CREST Shake. All describe a lightweight metal substrate wearing a wood-shake face. It is a subset of the wider metal roofing types family, sitting alongside standing seam and corrugated panels but built for looks rather than clean modern lines.

Shake profile vs shingle profile vs stone-coated: how the sub-types differ

Buyers routinely lump three different products together. A shake profile mimics thick, rough cedar with deep shadow lines. A shingle profile mimics flat or dimensional asphalt and reads much smoother. Stone-coated is a finish, not a shape: DECRA describes its Shake XD panel as steel with an aluminum-zinc alloy coating, acrylic primer, basecoat, stone granules and overglaze. Knowing which you are pricing prevents a mismatched quote.

Type What it imitates Surface finish Best for
Shake profile metal Hand-split cedar shakes Painted (PVDF) or stone-coated Rustic, craftsman, and lodge-style homes
Shingle profile metal Asphalt architectural shingles Painted, smoother face Conventional suburban rooflines
Stone-coated steel Shake, tile, or slate (finish, not form) Acrylic-bonded stone granules Hiding dents and softening rain noise

If you want the smoother look of asphalt rather than wood, see our companion guide on metal roofs that look like shingles.

How much does shake style metal roofing cost in 2026?

HomeGuide’s metal shingle cost guide puts installed metal shingles at $6 to $14 per square foot, or $600 to $1,600 per roofing square (100 square feet) depending on metal, with stone-coated steel at $7 to $13 per square foot. Shake profiles are one style within that category, so expect quotes in the same band, with steep pitches and complex rooflines pushing toward the top.

Material Material cost per square Installed cost per square Notes Source
Aluminum shake $325 to $650 $670 to $1,600 Does not rust; Classic and Interlock lines HomeGuide
Steel shake $300 to $500 $600 to $1,300 Stiffer, often lower material cost than aluminum HomeGuide
Stone-coated steel shake $370 to $580 $720 to $1,280 Textured granule finish hides denting HomeGuide
Real cedar shake (comparison) Not listed $2,500 to $3,000 $25 to $30 per sq ft installed HomeGuide cedar guide (November 2025)

Cost per year of service makes the comparison concrete. A stone-coated shake roof at $1,280 per square, the top of HomeGuide’s range, spread over the 50-year term of Westlake Royal’s PINE-CREST warranty works out to $25.60 per square per year. Real cedar at $2,500 to $3,000 per square over the 30 to 50 year life HomeGuide gives it with maintenance works out to $50 to $100 per square per year. Cross-check service lives in our roofing material lifespan report, and our metal shingle roof cost guide puts the per-square price next to the other stamped profiles.

Top shake style metal roofing brands compared

Five lines are in production: DECRA and Unified Steel use stone-coated steel, Classic Metal Roofing Systems and Interlock form aluminum, and ProVia stamps 26-gauge galvanized steel. CertainTeed’s Matterhorn Metal Shake, often listed alongside them, was discontinued in December 2020, per CertainTeed’s Matterhorn update, so it matters only for repairs to existing roofs.

Brand and product Material Weight per square Ratings Minimum pitch Warranty Source
DECRA Shake XD Stone-coated steel, aluminum-zinc coated 150 lb (23.4 panels, 12-3/8 x 49-7/8 in. exposure) Class A fire; Class 4 impact 3:12, direct to deck Lifetime limited for wind up to 120 mph and hail up to 2.5 in.; 30-year finish DECRA brochure; True Metal Supply
Classic Metal Country Manor Shake .019 in. 3105-H25 aluminum 46 lb 120 mph; UL 580 uplift; Class A, B or C fire depending on assembly; ICC-ES ESR-1360 3:12, or 4:12 in snow areas Transferable lifetime limited Classic Metal Roofing Systems
Interlock Metal Shake .028 in. aluminum (3003-H24 or 3105-H24, ASTM B209) About 58 lb UL 2218 Class 4 hail See maker spec sheet Limited lifetime, transferable Interlock
ProVia Metal Shake 26-gauge galvanized steel Not published Certified to 180 mph wind See maker spec sheet Lifetime limited ProVia; Mueller
Unified Steel PINE-CREST Shake Stone-coated Galvalume steel Not published Class 4 impact; FM Very Severe Hail; Class A fire; HVHZ wind See maker spec sheet Transferable 50-year limited Westlake Royal
CertainTeed Matterhorn Metal Shake Steel Discontinued December 2020 CertainTeed

DECRA’s stone-coated system is common enough that it warrants its own breakdown; see our DECRA stone-coated metal roofing guide for profile-by-profile pricing on that line.

Unified Steel’s PINE-CREST Shake carries forward the former Metro Shake II and replaced the discontinued Gerard Canyon Shake, though not at a matching panel size, per Westlake Royal’s discontinued-panel bulletin UNS550300 (revised March 2026). For that lineage, see our guide to Gerard and Unified Steel shake profiles.

Shake style metal roofing vs real cedar shake

Metal shake wins on upfront cost, fire rating, weight and maintenance; real cedar wins on natural texture up close. HomeGuide prices real cedar shake at $25 to $30 per square foot installed, roughly double the top of its $6 to $14 metal shingle range, and gives cedar a 30 to 50 year life with maintenance. The metal lines above carry 50-year to lifetime limited warranties, and several list a Class A fire rating.

  • Lifespan: Metal shake warranties run 50 years (Unified Steel PINE-CREST) to lifetime limited (DECRA, Classic, Interlock); HomeGuide gives cedar shake 30 to 50 years with maintenance.
  • Weight: Metal shake runs 46 lb per square (Classic, aluminum) to 150 lb per square (DECRA Shake XD), light enough that framing reinforcement is rarely the deciding issue.
  • Fire: DECRA Shake XD and PINE-CREST list Class A; Classic Country Manor Shake is eligible for Class A, B or C depending on the assembly beneath it. Untreated cedar does not carry a Class A rating on its own and is restricted in many wildfire zones.
  • Maintenance: Cedar needs periodic cleaning, treatment, and shake replacement, detailed in our synthetic cedar shake roofing comparison of the low-maintenance alternatives.
  • Look up close: Cedar and premium polymer shakes still read more natural at arm’s length than stamped metal, though stone-coated finishes narrow the gap.

Pros and cons of shake style metal roofing

Shake style metal roofing offers cedar’s dimensional look at half or less of the installed price HomeGuide gives real cedar, but it costs more upfront than architectural asphalt (about $5 to $9 per square foot in the same HomeGuide comparison) and can dent or amplify rain noise if detailed poorly. Weigh these trade-offs against how long you plan to own the home and your local fire and hail exposure.

Pros

  • Class A fire and Class 4 impact ratings on DECRA Shake XD and PINE-CREST, which Westlake Royal says can meet the design needs for most insurance discounts; ask your carrier what it offers in your state.
  • Will not rot, split, warp, or host insects and moss the way real cedar does.
  • Light enough (46 to 150 lb per square) to go over one existing layer where allowed; IRC R908.3.1.1 bars a re-cover over two or more existing layers.
  • Reflective finishes, such as Classic’s hI-R coating and the integral airspace under its panels, can lower cooling load in hot climates.

Cons

  • Higher upfront cost than asphalt.
  • Smooth-finish panels can show hail dents; stone-coated versions hide them better.
  • Rain noise rises without adequate underlayment or attic insulation.
  • Fewer crews are trained on shake metal detailing, so ask for the maker’s installer certification.

How shake style metal roofing is installed

Installation follows a sequence close to other metal shingle systems, with attention to underlayment and the shadow-line coursing that sells the cedar look. IRC R905.4.2 bars metal roof shingles below a 3:12 slope, DECRA lists 3:12 for Shake XD direct to deck, and Classic raises its minimum to 4:12 in snow areas.

  1. Inspect the roof and tear off where code requires (two or more existing layers under IRC R908.3.1.1), then repair any rotted decking.
  2. Confirm the slope is at least 3:12 (4:12 for Classic in snow areas), then install the manufacturer-specified underlayment, plus ice and water shield at eaves and valleys in cold climates.
  3. Set eave starter and rake trim to lock the first course and establish drainage.
  4. Fasten panels or interlocking shakes course by course at the maker’s exposure (12-3/8 in. for DECRA Shake XD), staggering seams so the shadow lines read as random cedar.
  5. Flash all penetrations, valleys, and walls, then cap the ridge and hips with matching shake trim.

Which metal shake to choose

If… Choose Rule or source
The roof slope is under 3:12 Not a metal shake; consider standing seam IRC R905.4.2
You are in a snow area with a slope between 3:12 and 4:12 A product rated for that slope; Classic Country Manor Shake needs 4:12 there Classic Metal Roofing Systems
The house is near salt water Aluminum (Classic .019 in. or Interlock .028 in.) Aluminum does not rust
Hail is your main risk A UL 2218 Class 4 line: DECRA Shake XD, Interlock or PINE-CREST Maker ratings; check your insurer’s discount
Framing capacity is limited Aluminum at 46 to 58 lb per square rather than stone-coated steel at 150 lb Classic, Interlock, DECRA specs
The roof already has two or more layers Full tear-off before any metal shake IRC R908.3.1.1
You are in a wildfire zone A Class A listed product or assembly (DECRA Shake XD, PINE-CREST) Maker fire listings

Is shake style metal roofing worth it?

Shake style metal roofing is usually worth it for owners who want a cedar look at a lower price per year than real cedar ($25.60 versus $50 to $100 per square per year in the example above), or in wildfire and hail zones where Class A and Class 4 ratings earn insurance value. For a short hold or a tight budget, architectural asphalt at $5 to $9 per square foot or a polymer shake often returns more per dollar.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a metal shake roof cost?

HomeGuide puts installed metal shingles, the category metal shake belongs to, at $6 to $14 per square foot, or $600 to $1,600 per roofing square depending on metal: steel $600 to $1,300, stone-coated steel $720 to $1,280 and aluminum $670 to $1,600 per square. Steep pitches and complex rooflines push quotes toward the top. Real cedar shake runs $25 to $30 per square foot installed in HomeGuide’s cedar guide.

Does a metal shake roof look real?

From the ground, quality metal shake reads as cedar because panels are stamped with varied shake heights and deep shadow lines; Classic Metal Roofing Systems forms each Country Manor Shake panel to look like eight shakes of varying height, width and thickness. Up close, stamped metal is still distinguishable from wood, though stone-coated granule surfaces such as DECRA Shake XD narrow the gap more than smooth painted panels do.

How long does shake style metal roofing last?

Warranties are the clearest published measure: Unified Steel PINE-CREST Shake carries a transferable 50-year limited warranty, and DECRA, Classic Metal Roofing Systems and Interlock offer lifetime limited coverage. HomeGuide puts metal roofs at 30 to 80 years and real cedar shake at 30 to 50 years with maintenance. Aluminum lines suit coastal, salt-air sites because aluminum does not rust.

What is the difference between metal shake and stone-coated steel?

Metal shake describes the shape, a panel formed to imitate cedar shakes. Stone-coated steel describes the finish: on DECRA Shake XD, steel with an aluminum-zinc coating, acrylic primer, basecoat, stone granules and overglaze. Many shake profiles are stone-coated, but shake metal can also be painted, as on Classic’s aluminum Country Manor Shake. Stone coating adds texture that hides dents and softens rain noise.

Is metal shake roofing the same as a metal roof that looks like asphalt shingles?

No. Shake metal imitates thick, rough cedar with deep shadow lines, while a metal roof that looks like asphalt shingles copies the flatter architectural-shingle profile. They use similar steel or aluminum substrates and the same 3:12 minimum slope under IRC R905.4.2, but target different looks, so confirm which profile a quote covers before comparing prices.

Can shake style metal roofing be installed over an existing roof?

Often, if there is only one existing layer: IRC R908.3.1.1 bars a re-cover over two or more layers, and metal shake adds only 46 to 150 pounds per square depending on the product. Local code, decking condition, and the manufacturer’s warranty terms decide whether an overlay is allowed. A tear-off lets the crew repair rotted decking and avoids trapped moisture.

Is CertainTeed Matterhorn metal shake still made?

No. CertainTeed discontinued its Matterhorn Metal Roofing line effective December 2020, per the company’s Matterhorn update page. Current shake-profile metal lines include DECRA Shake XD, Classic Metal Roofing Systems Country Manor Shake, Interlock Metal Shake, ProVia Metal Shake and Unified Steel PINE-CREST Shake.