Subscribe

INDUSTRY REPORTS · July 25, 2026

Wage Theft in Roofing (2026): DOL Back Wages and Violation Rates

How much wage theft hits roofing: DOL back-wage recoveries, misclassification rates, and an estimate of affected roofers. 2026 data brief.

A data brief by The Roofing Brief Team. Figures cited inline to named primary sources. Last reviewed: October 2026.

Headline finding: Wage theft in roofing likely affects 20,000 to 35,000 workers. Applying the national construction misclassification rate of 12% to 21% (Ormiston, Belman and Erlich, 2020) to the roofing workforce of 166,700 workers (BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook, 2024) yields an estimated 20,000 to 35,000 roofing workers who are likely misclassified as independent contractors or paid off the books in a typical month. That estimate is this brief’s original synthesis, not a measured roofing-specific count, and the methodology and limits are stated below. Wage theft in roofing is not a set of isolated bad actors: federal enforcement, academic prevalence studies, and state audits all point to a trade where underpayment is structural.

How much wage theft happens in roofing?

Wage theft in roofing most often takes the form of unpaid overtime, misclassification as independent contractors, and off-the-books cash pay. No agency publishes a single roofing-only prevalence figure, so the scale is triangulated from three data streams: U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) Wage and Hour Division recoveries, peer-reviewed construction payroll-fraud studies, and state audit programs. Each is a partial view, and together they describe a trade with above-average exposure.

The clearest hard number is recovered back wages. In fiscal year 2023, the DOL Wage and Hour Division recovered more than $35.5 million in back wages for construction workers across 2,134 cases, the highest dollar total of any industry that year (DOL Wage and Hour Division, FY2023). Roofing sits inside that construction total, and individual roofing judgments regularly run into six and seven figures.

The largest DOL back-wage recoveries against roofing contractors

Federal roofing enforcement clusters around one violation: paying installers a flat piece rate or day rate and then not paying the time-and-one-half overtime premium once they pass 40 hours in a week. The table below ranks recent DOL Wage and Hour Division roofing judgments by back wages recovered. Each row is drawn from a DOL press release, so these are confirmed recoveries, not allegations.

Roofing employer (location) Year Back wages recovered Workers Civil penalties Core violation
Northern California Nail Co. Inc. (Livermore, CA) 2025 $1,943,685 158 $56,314 Unpaid overtime, recordkeeping
JAJ Roofing, dba Citadel Roofing & Solar (Vacaville, CA) 2021 $845,090 385 $319,550 Piece-rate, no overtime premium
Orion Builders Service Inc. (Florida) Reported $265,001 67 $17,753 Overtime, repeat violation
Mohawk Valley roofing contractor (New York) 2023 $166,000 53 Not stated Denied overtime
Collum Roofing (Arizona) 2026 $147,708 61 Not stated Overtime, consent judgment

Source: U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division news releases, 2021 to 2026. Amounts include back wages and, where noted separately, civil money penalties. “Reported” denotes a DOL-confirmed recovery for which the release year was not captured in this dataset.

Two patterns stand out. First, the piece-rate trap is the recurring mechanism: at Citadel Roofing & Solar, investigators found installers paid by the piece averaged 47 hours a week while payroll recorded only 40 (DOL Wage and Hour Division, 2021). Second, penalties can rival the back wages: the $319,550 civil penalty in that case was, at the time, the second highest ever assessed by the division’s Western region (DOL Wage and Hour Division, 2021).

How does roofing rank within construction for wage violations?

Construction is the single largest source of federal back-wage recoveries, and roofing carries several of the risk factors that concentrate violations. The trade is heavily residential, heavily subcontracted, and staffed disproportionately by immigrant and Hispanic workers, the three characteristics that construction wage-theft researchers most consistently link to underpayment (UC Berkeley Labor Center, 2022).

Across all of construction, a landmark national study estimated that in an average month of 2017, between 12% and 21% of construction workers were misclassified as independent contractors or paid strictly off the books, rising to 13% to 22% in the peak summer building months (Ormiston, Belman and Erlich, 2020). The same study found construction had the most misclassification of any industry, and calculated that payroll fraud let contractors cut labor costs by $6.2 billion to $11.7 billion a year (Ormiston, Belman and Erlich, 2020).

The off-the-books share matters most for roofing crews. The UC Berkeley Labor Center estimated that roughly 1.2 million U.S. construction workers are paid entirely off the books, and that 39% of construction worker families rely on at least one safety-net program, at a public cost of about $28 billion a year (Jacobs, Huang, MacGillvary and Lopezlira, UC Berkeley Labor Center, 2022).

What is roofer misclassification, and why does it enable wage theft?

Misclassification is labeling a worker who functions as an employee as an “independent contractor” or a “1099 subcontractor.” It is the gateway to most roofing wage theft because a worker treated as a contractor can be denied overtime, minimum wage, workers’ compensation, and unemployment insurance, and bears the full payroll-tax burden themselves. Classifying a roofer as a contractor rather than an employee cuts a contractor’s labor cost by about 26% (Hennepin County Attorney, 2021).

Misclassification also underbids honest firms. A contractor who dodges payroll taxes, overtime, and workers’ compensation premiums can quote a lower price on the same roof, which pressures compliant competitors to cut corners too. Because roofing carries some of the highest workers’ compensation rates in construction, the premium avoided per misclassified roofer is larger than in most other trades (UC Berkeley Labor Center, 2022). Our guide to cheap roofing insurance explains why roofing comp rates run so high and how compliant firms lower their premiums.

If X, then Y: using the wage-theft numbers

If this is the situation Then
A roofer is paid a flat piece or day rate and works past 40 hours Overtime at one and one-half times the regular rate is owed under 29 U.S.C. 207(a); at Citadel Roofing & Solar, piece-rate installers averaged 47 hours while payroll showed 40.
A subcontractor offers 1099 “labor-only” pay Treat the status as unproven: employers save about 26% of labor cost by misclassifying, and the national construction rate is 12% to 21%.
Pay is in cash with no records Keep your own log of hours and pay; about 1.2 million construction workers are paid entirely off the books.
A prime contractor hires layered subcontractors Expect liability to follow the work: the Citadel case drew $845,090 in back wages plus a $319,550 civil penalty.
You need a local scale estimate Use the state audit range of 12% (Rhode Island employers) to 47%+ (Indiana firms), and note firms versus workers differ.

Where is construction misclassification worst? State audit rates

State payroll audits give the closest thing to a prevalence map: Indiana found 47%+ of audited construction firms misclassifying, Kentucky and Michigan 26%, Rhode Island 12% of employers. Methods differ, but every study finds construction misclassification well above the all-industry baseline. These figures cover all construction trades, not roofing alone, and roofing plausibly runs at or above the construction average given its residential and subcontracted structure.

State / study Misclassification or off-books rate Basis
Indiana (Kelsay & Sturgeon) 47%+ of audited construction firms Firms actively misclassifying
Kentucky (Kelsay & Sturgeon, 2011) 26% of audited firms Firms actively misclassifying
Michigan (Belman & Block, 2009) 26% of audited firms Firms actively misclassifying
Minnesota (Goodell & Manzo, IV) 23% of construction workers Misclassified or paid off books
Missouri (Kelsay, 2023) 21% of construction workers Misclassified or off the books
New York (state task-force data) 18% of construction workers Misclassified
Rhode Island (Ormiston & Juravich, 2022) 12% of construction employers Employers misclassifying

Sources: state misclassification studies compiled by the Hennepin County Attorney (2021) and the Foundation for Fair Contracting (2023). Rates are not directly comparable because studies differ in whether they count firms or workers and in the years measured.

In Minnesota specifically, researchers estimated about 30,100 construction workers, or 23% of the state’s construction workforce, were misclassified or paid off the books, and that those workers earned about 36% less, near $29,700 a year less, than lawfully employed peers (Goodell and Manzo, cited in Hennepin County Attorney, 2021).

Why are roofers especially exposed to wage theft?

Roofing concentrates the exact conditions that drive construction wage theft. The work is short-duration and residential, so crews cycle through many small jobs where oversight is thin. Pay is frequently structured as a piece rate or a day rate, which is where the unpaid-overtime cases originate. And the workforce skews toward immigrant and Hispanic labor, groups that studies repeatedly identify as most likely to experience wage theft and least able to challenge it (UC Berkeley Labor Center, 2022).

  • Piece-rate and day-rate pay. Flat pay per square or per day masks hours worked, so the overtime premium disappears once a crew passes 40 hours (DOL Wage and Hour Division, 2021).
  • Labor brokers and layered subcontracting. A prime hires a “labor-only” subcontractor who pays workers in cash with no withholding, distancing the general contractor from liability (UC Berkeley Labor Center, 2022).
  • High workers’ compensation cost. Roofing’s injury and fatality profile makes its comp premiums among the steepest in construction, so misclassification, which cuts an employer’s labor cost by about 26% (Hennepin County Attorney, 2021), saves more per worker.
  • Immigration-status pressure. Threats to report workers to immigration authorities are documented as a tool to avoid paying wages in construction, including on roofing crews (findings summarized by CPWR and press reporting, 2025; background at the UC Berkeley Labor Center).

For the wider labor picture behind these figures, see The Roofing Brief’s Roofing Workforce Demographics Report on who roofs America, and the 2026 Roofing Labor Wage Report on pay and the workforce shortage.

What counts as wage theft on a roofing crew?

Wage theft is any failure to pay a worker all wages legally earned. On roofing jobs it typically appears as one or more of the following, each of which can trigger DOL Wage and Hour Division back-wage liability under the Fair Labor Standards Act. Whether a given practice is unlawful can depend on state law and on the worker’s true employment status.

  1. Unpaid overtime. Not paying time-and-one-half for hours past 40 in a workweek (29 U.S.C. 207(a)), the most common roofing violation in DOL cases; 29 U.S.C. 216(b) makes the employer liable for the unpaid overtime plus an equal amount as liquidated damages.
  2. Misclassification. Treating an employee as a 1099 contractor to avoid overtime, minimum wage, and payroll taxes.
  3. Off-the-clock work. Not counting travel between jobs, load-in, or setup as paid time.
  4. Cash pay with no records. Paying off the books, which erases the paper trail a worker needs to prove hours.
  5. Minimum-wage shortfalls. Piece-rate earnings that, divided by actual hours, fall below the applicable minimum wage.
  6. Prevailing-wage violations. On public roofing projects, paying below the required Davis-Bacon or state prevailing rate.

A worker who suspects unpaid wages can file a confidential complaint with the DOL Wage and Hour Division, which may investigate regardless of immigration status. Many states also run their own wage-claim processes with shorter timelines. Roofers comparing pay and conditions across trades can review the Roofing vs the Other Skilled Trades report and current roofer pay by state.

Methodology note

This brief triangulates three source types. First, back-wage recoveries come directly from U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division news releases (2021 to 2026), each naming the employer, dollar amount, and worker count. Second, prevalence figures come from peer-reviewed and university research, principally Ormiston, Belman and Erlich (2020) and the UC Berkeley Labor Center (2022), plus state studies compiled by the Hennepin County Attorney (2021) and the Foundation for Fair Contracting (2023). Third, the roofing workforce base of 166,700 comes from the BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook (2024 data). The headline estimate multiplies that workforce by the national construction misclassification and off-books range of 12% to 21% (Ormiston, Belman and Erlich, 2020) to produce a defensible order-of-magnitude figure of 20,000 to 35,000 affected roofing workers.

Limitations note

These figures are directional, not precise. DOL back-wage totals, such as the $35.5 million recovered in construction in FY2023, capture only detected and litigated cases, so they are a floor on actual theft, not a measure of prevalence. No published study isolates a roofing-only misclassification rate, so the headline estimate applies the all-construction rate as a proxy; roofing may run above that average given its residential, piece-rate, and immigrant-heavy structure, which would make the true figure higher. State audit rates are not directly comparable because they differ in method, in whether they count firms or workers, and in year. Prevalence studies center on misclassification and off-the-books pay and do not capture every form of underpayment. Readers should treat all ranges as conditional estimates that vary by state, employment structure, and enforcement intensity.

Frequently asked questions

Is wage theft common in the roofing industry?

Wage theft is widespread in roofing. National research found that in an average month, 12% to 21% of construction workers were misclassified as independent contractors or paid off the books (Ormiston, Belman and Erlich, 2020). Applied to the 166,700 U.S. roofers (BLS, 2024), that implies roughly 20,000 to 35,000 roofing workers are likely affected, an order-of-magnitude estimate rather than an exact count.

How much money does the DOL recover from roofing contractors?

Individual roofing judgments regularly reach six and seven figures. In 2025 a Northern California roofing contractor was ordered to pay $1,943,685 to 158 workers for unpaid overtime, and in 2021 Citadel Roofing and Solar paid $845,090 to 385 workers plus a $319,550 civil penalty (DOL Wage and Hour Division). Construction overall drew more than $35.5 million in FY2023, the highest of any industry.

What is roofer misclassification?

Misclassification is labeling a worker who functions as an employee as an independent contractor or 1099 subcontractor. It lets an employer avoid overtime, minimum wage, workers’ compensation, and payroll taxes, and shifts those costs onto the worker. Treating a roofer as a contractor instead of an employee cuts an employer’s labor cost by about 26% (Hennepin County Attorney, 2021).

Why are roofers especially vulnerable to wage theft?

Roofing concentrates the conditions that drive construction wage theft: short residential jobs with thin oversight, piece-rate and day-rate pay that hides hours, layered subcontracting through labor brokers, and a workforce with a high immigrant and Hispanic share that studies find is most exposed to underpayment (UC Berkeley Labor Center, 2022). Roofing’s high workers’ compensation cost also increases what an employer saves by misclassifying.

Is it illegal to pay roofers in cash?

Paying in cash is not automatically illegal, but it becomes wage theft when the employer keeps no accurate time records, skips overtime, pays below minimum wage, or avoids payroll taxes and workers’ compensation. Off-the-books cash pay erases the record a worker needs to prove hours. The UC Berkeley Labor Center estimated about 1.2 million construction workers are paid entirely off the books (2022).

What can a roofer do about unpaid overtime?

A roofer owed overtime can file a confidential complaint with the U.S. Department of Labor Wage and Hour Division, which may investigate regardless of immigration status and can recover back wages under the Fair Labor Standards Act. Many states also run wage-claim processes, often with shorter filing deadlines. Keeping personal records of hours and pay strengthens any claim. Specifics vary by state and employment status.