By The Roofing Brief Team. Last reviewed: October 2026.
The Roofing Affordability Index ranks all 50 US states by how expensive a typical roof replacement is relative to local median household income. It divides an estimated state roof replacement cost by the state median household income from the 2023 American Community Survey, then ranks states from least affordable to most affordable. In the October 2026 edition, West Virginia is the least affordable state for roof replacement at 15.96% of median annual household income, and Maryland is the most affordable at 9.05%. Roof cost sits inside a much larger building economy, sized in our US roofing construction spending report.
Every income figure is read from Table 1 of the Census Bureau brief ACSBR-023 (ACS 2023 1-year, Table B19013), every state roof cost figure is a labeled estimate ($9,600 baseline times a state cost factor), and the formula is published in the Methodology so any state can be recomputed. An October 28, 2026 re-check against ACSBR-023 corrected two incomes: Alaska ($88,121 to $86,631) and Delaware ($82,174 to $81,361), moving Alaska from 6th to 4th and Delaware from 23rd to 20th.
Executive Summary
- The US national median household income was $77,719 in 2023 (Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 1-year, 2023).
- The national average cost to replace a residential roof was approximately $9,600: HomeAdvisor’s June 17, 2026 update gives a $9,610 national average with most homeowners paying $5,903 to $13,378 (Source: HomeAdvisor), and NerdWallet, citing Angi, gives $9,500.
- West Virginia is the least affordable state in the index: an estimated $8,928 roof replacement equals 15.96% of its $55,948 median household income (calculated from Census ACS 2023 income and an estimated state roof cost).
- Maryland is the most affordable state: an estimated $8,928 roof replacement equals 9.05% of its $98,678 median household income (calculated from Census ACS 2023 income and an estimated state roof cost).
- The median state in the index spends 12.09% of one year of median household income on a typical roof replacement, and the mean across 50 states is 12.02% (Roofing Brief calculation, October 2026).
- The gap between the least and most affordable state is 6.9 percentage points of annual income, a difference driven more by income than by construction cost, because the highest-cost state multiplier (1.25) is only about 1.56 times the lowest (0.80), while the highest state income ($99,858) is about 1.84 times the lowest ($54,203).
- Eight of the ten least affordable states had 2023 median household incomes below the national median of $77,719 (Census ACS 2023), confirming that income, not raw price, is the dominant driver of roofing unaffordability.
Key Findings
- Mississippi had the lowest 2023 median household income of any state at $54,203 (Census ACS 1-year, 2023).
- West Virginia had the second-lowest 2023 median household income at $55,948 and ranks as the least affordable state for roof replacement in this index (Census ACS 2023; Roofing Brief calculation, 2026).
- Massachusetts had the highest state median household income at $99,858 in 2023, just ahead of New Jersey at $99,781 (Census ACS 2023).
- The estimated state roof replacement cost ranged from $7,680 in Mississippi, Arkansas, and North Carolina (0.80 cost multiplier) to $12,000 in Alaska (1.25 multiplier), based on a $9,600 national average and state construction-cost factors (Roofing Brief estimate using Roof Observations 2026 state factors).
- Roofing materials rose 45% between 2019 and May 2026, versus 31% for the Consumer Price Index, per The Roofing Brief’s Roofing Material Price Inflation Index (BLS Producer Price Index data).
- Michigan ranks second-least affordable at 14.29% of income, the result of a 1.03 construction multiplier paired with a below-median $69,183 household income (Census ACS 2023; Roofing Brief calculation, 2026).
- New York ranks fifth-least affordable at 13.80% of income, just behind Alaska (13.85%), because its 1.18 construction multiplier produces an estimated $11,328 roof cost against $82,095 income (Roofing Brief calculation, 2026).
- Maryland, Virginia, Utah, New Hampshire, and Colorado are the five most affordable states, each below 9.5% of annual income, all combining above-average income with at-or-below-average construction costs (Roofing Brief calculation, 2026).
- Alaska has the highest estimated absolute roof cost in the index at $12,000, yet ranks fourth-least affordable at 13.85% rather than first because its $86,631 median income is above the $77,719 national median (Census ACS 2023; Roofing Brief calculation, 2026).
- California carries the second-highest construction multiplier among the contiguous states at 1.15, but its $95,521 median income places it at a mid-pack 11.56% affordability ratio (Roofing Brief calculation, 2026).
- The United States had 24,532 employer roofing contractor establishments in 2022, per The Roofing Brief’s US Roofing Contractor Count Report (U.S. Census Bureau County Business Patterns, NAICS 238160).
- HomeAdvisor’s June 2026 update prices contractor labor at about $200 to $300 per roofing square (100 sq ft) before materials, plus $1,000 to $3,000 for tear-off and $500 to $1,500 for hauling and disposal (HomeAdvisor, 2026). Roof Observations describes its state factors as an average of labor, materials and local market conditions.
The Roofing Affordability Index: Full State Ranking
The table below ranks all 50 states from least affordable (rank 1, highest cost-to-income ratio) to most affordable (rank 50). The affordability ratio is the estimated roof replacement cost divided by the 2023 median household income, expressed as a percentage of one year of household income. Income figures and their 90% margins of error are from Table 1 of Census brief ACSBR-023 (ACS 2023 1-year), e.g. Rhode Island $84,972 ±$2,566 and New Hampshire $96,838 ±$2,243. Roof cost figures are clearly labeled estimates derived from a $9,600 national average and a state construction-cost multiplier, as explained in the Methodology.
| Rank | State | Median household income (ACS 2023 1-year) | Margin of error (90%) | State cost factor | Estimated roof cost | Affordability ratio (% of annual income) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | West Virginia | $55,948 | ±$1,052 | 0.93 | $8,928 | 15.96% |
| 2 | Michigan | $69,183 | ±$694 | 1.03 | $9,888 | 14.29% |
| 3 | Mississippi | $54,203 | ±$1,260 | 0.80 | $7,680 | 14.17% |
| 4 | Alaska | $86,631 | ±$2,575 | 1.25 | $12,000 | 13.85% |
| 5 | New York | $82,095 | ±$500 | 1.18 | $11,328 | 13.80% |
| 6 | Kentucky | $61,118 | ±$653 | 0.87 | $8,352 | 13.67% |
| 7 | Alabama | $62,212 | ±$711 | 0.88 | $8,448 | 13.58% |
| 8 | New Mexico | $62,268 | ±$1,281 | 0.88 | $8,448 | 13.57% |
| 9 | Louisiana | $58,229 | ±$1,143 | 0.82 | $7,872 | 13.52% |
| 10 | Missouri | $68,545 | ±$900 | 0.95 | $9,120 | 13.31% |
| 11 | Illinois | $80,306 | ±$635 | 1.10 | $10,560 | 13.15% |
| 12 | Arkansas | $58,700 | ±$1,155 | 0.80 | $7,680 | 13.08% |
| 13 | Iowa | $71,433 | ±$1,135 | 0.97 | $9,312 | 13.04% |
| 14 | Ohio | $67,769 | ±$731 | 0.92 | $8,832 | 13.03% |
| 15 | Oregon | $80,160 | ±$1,045 | 1.08 | $10,368 | 12.93% |
| 16 | Oklahoma | $62,138 | ±$480 | 0.83 | $7,968 | 12.82% |
| 17 | Wisconsin | $74,631 | ±$774 | 0.99 | $9,504 | 12.73% |
| 18 | Pennsylvania | $73,824 | ±$511 | 0.96 | $9,216 | 12.48% |
| 19 | Indiana | $69,477 | ±$808 | 0.90 | $8,640 | 12.44% |
| 20 | Delaware | $81,361 | ±$1,668 | 1.05 | $10,080 | 12.39% |
| 21 | Connecticut | $91,665 | ±$1,473 | 1.18 | $11,328 | 12.36% |
| 22 | Montana | $70,804 | ±$1,475 | 0.91 | $8,736 | 12.34% |
| 23 | Kansas | $70,333 | ±$1,182 | 0.90 | $8,640 | 12.28% |
| 24 | South Carolina | $67,804 | ±$1,049 | 0.86 | $8,256 | 12.18% |
| 25 | Rhode Island | $84,972 | ±$2,566 | 1.07 | $10,272 | 12.09% |
| 26 | Hawaii | $95,322 | ±$2,478 | 1.20 | $11,520 | 12.09% |
| 27 | Tennessee | $67,631 | ±$865 | 0.85 | $8,160 | 12.07% |
| 28 | Minnesota | $85,086 | ±$768 | 1.06 | $10,176 | 11.96% |
| 29 | Nevada | $76,364 | ±$1,451 | 0.95 | $9,120 | 11.94% |
| 30 | Wyoming | $72,415 | ±$2,357 | 0.90 | $8,640 | 11.93% |
| 31 | South Dakota | $71,810 | ±$2,132 | 0.89 | $8,544 | 11.90% |
| 32 | California | $95,521 | ±$611 | 1.15 | $11,040 | 11.56% |
| 33 | North Dakota | $76,525 | ±$1,844 | 0.92 | $8,832 | 11.54% |
| 34 | Massachusetts | $99,858 | ±$1,355 | 1.18 | $11,328 | 11.34% |
| 35 | Nebraska | $74,590 | ±$1,340 | 0.88 | $8,448 | 11.33% |
| 36 | Georgia | $74,632 | ±$833 | 0.88 | $8,448 | 11.32% |
| 37 | Idaho | $74,942 | ±$1,126 | 0.88 | $8,448 | 11.27% |
| 38 | Maine | $73,733 | ±$1,699 | 0.86 | $8,256 | 11.20% |
| 39 | Florida | $73,311 | ±$577 | 0.85 | $8,160 | 11.13% |
| 40 | North Carolina | $70,804 | ±$547 | 0.80 | $7,680 | 10.85% |
| 41 | New Jersey | $99,781 | ±$1,061 | 1.11 | $10,656 | 10.68% |
| 42 | Arizona | $77,315 | ±$931 | 0.86 | $8,256 | 10.68% |
| 43 | Washington | $94,605 | ±$1,221 | 1.05 | $10,080 | 10.65% |
| 44 | Texas | $75,780 | ±$472 | 0.82 | $7,872 | 10.39% |
| 45 | Vermont | $81,211 | ±$2,608 | 0.85 | $8,160 | 10.05% |
| 46 | Colorado | $92,911 | ±$1,057 | 0.91 | $8,736 | 9.40% |
| 47 | New Hampshire | $96,838 | ±$2,243 | 0.93 | $8,928 | 9.22% |
| 48 | Utah | $93,421 | ±$1,383 | 0.89 | $8,544 | 9.15% |
| 49 | Virginia | $89,931 | ±$970 | 0.85 | $8,160 | 9.07% |
| 50 | Maryland | $98,678 | ±$1,292 | 0.93 | $8,928 | 9.05% |
The index spans a 6.91 percentage point range, from 9.05% in Maryland to 15.96% in West Virginia. A state’s rank reflects the interaction of two inputs: the local construction cost factor and the local median household income. States cluster near the 12% median because moderate construction costs and moderate incomes tend to offset each other, while the extremes appear where the two inputs diverge sharply in the same direction. If you are pricing a roof in West Virginia, we rank roofers in Charleston and Wheeling.
Least Affordable States for Roof Replacement
The ten least affordable states share a common pattern: median household incomes at or below the national median, with construction costs that are average or above. West Virginia tops the list because it pairs the second-lowest state income ($55,948) with a construction factor (0.93) that sits only modestly below the national 1.00, so roof costs fall less than income does. Michigan is second because its 1.03 construction multiplier sits above the national average while its income ($69,183) sits below it. For local pricing detail, see what a roof costs in Michigan.
| Rank | State | Affordability ratio | Median income (ACS 2023) | Estimated roof cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | West Virginia | 15.96% | $55,948 | $8,928 |
| 2 | Michigan | 14.29% | $69,183 | $9,888 |
| 3 | Mississippi | 14.17% | $54,203 | $7,680 |
| 4 | Alaska | 13.85% | $86,631 | $12,000 |
| 5 | New York | 13.80% | $82,095 | $11,328 |
| 6 | Kentucky | 13.67% | $61,118 | $8,352 |
| 7 | Alabama | 13.58% | $62,212 | $8,448 |
| 8 | New Mexico | 13.57% | $62,268 | $8,448 |
| 9 | Louisiana | 13.52% | $58,229 | $7,872 |
| 10 | Missouri | 13.31% | $68,545 | $9,120 |
Alaska and New York are the only two high-cost states in this group: their 1.25 and 1.18 multipliers produce estimated roof costs of $12,000 and $11,328, against incomes of $86,631 and $82,095 that sit above the $77,719 national median. The other eight states all had 2023 median incomes below $77,719, from $54,203 in Mississippi to $69,183 in Michigan.
Most Affordable States for Roof Replacement
The ten most affordable states combine above-median incomes with at-or-below-average construction costs. Maryland is the most affordable because it pairs the third-highest state income ($98,678; fourth if the District of Columbia is counted) with a below-average 0.93 construction factor. Virginia, Utah, New Hampshire, and Colorado follow the same logic.
| Rank | State | Affordability ratio | Median income (ACS 2023) | Estimated roof cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 41 | New Jersey | 10.68% | $99,781 | $10,656 |
| 42 | Arizona | 10.68% | $77,315 | $8,256 |
| 43 | Washington | 10.65% | $94,605 | $10,080 |
| 44 | Texas | 10.39% | $75,780 | $7,872 |
| 45 | Vermont | 10.05% | $81,211 | $8,160 |
| 46 | Colorado | 9.40% | $92,911 | $8,736 |
| 47 | New Hampshire | 9.22% | $96,838 | $8,928 |
| 48 | Utah | 9.15% | $93,421 | $8,544 |
| 49 | Virginia | 9.07% | $89,931 | $8,160 |
| 50 | Maryland | 9.05% | $98,678 | $8,928 |
Texas is the most affordable large-population state at 10.39%, driven by a low 0.82 construction multiplier and a near-national-median income. New Jersey appears here despite a high 1.11 construction multiplier because its $99,781 income is the second-highest in the country.
Roof Replacement Cost Inputs
The national average roof replacement cost used as the index baseline is $9,600, drawn from contractor cost aggregators. HomeAdvisor’s page updated June 17, 2026 reports a national average of $9,610, with most homeowners spending between $5,903 and $13,378 and $4 to $11 per square foot (Source: HomeAdvisor). NerdWallet, citing Angi, reports a $9,500 average with a $5,800 to $46,000 range. The two figures sit within 1.2% of each other, so the index keeps a rounded $9,600 baseline.
| Cost input | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| National average roof replacement | $9,610 | HomeAdvisor, updated June 17, 2026 |
| Typical range (most homeowners) | $5,903 to $13,378 | HomeAdvisor, June 2026 |
| National average (Angi data) | $9,500 | NerdWallet, 2026 |
| Index baseline used (rounded) | $9,600 | Roofing Brief, 2026 |
| Typical installed price per square foot | $4 to $11 (about $7 average) | HomeAdvisor, June 2026 |
| Contractor labor, materials excluded | $200 to $300 per square (100 sq ft) | HomeAdvisor, June 2026 |
| Old roof removal plus hauling | $1,000 to $3,000 plus $500 to $1,500 | HomeAdvisor, June 2026 |
| State cost factor range | 0.80 (AR, MS, NC) to 1.25 (AK); DC 1.02 | Roof Observations, updated January 11, 2026 |
Because labor, material delivery and local market conditions differ by state, the index applies a state construction-cost factor to the national baseline rather than treating roof cost as uniform. The state factors range from 0.80 (Arkansas, Mississippi, North Carolina) to 1.25 (Alaska), per construction-cost data compiled by Roof Observations (2026 update), which states that its figures are illustrative order-of-magnitude regional construction costs informed by RSMeans-style location factors. All state roof cost figures in this index are estimates and are labeled as such.
Affordability vs Median Income Context
The strongest pattern in the index is that median household income predicts affordability rank better than roof price does. The construction-cost multiplier spans a 1.56x range (0.80 to 1.25), while state median household income spans a 1.84x range ($54,203 in Mississippi to $99,858 in Massachusetts). Because income varies more than cost, income is the dominant variable.
This shows up at both extremes. Mississippi has the lowest construction multiplier in the country (0.80, tied), which puts its estimated roof at $7,680, yet it ranks third-least affordable at 14.17% because its $54,203 income is the lowest in the nation. Massachusetts has one of the highest construction multipliers (1.18), which should make it expensive, yet it ranks 34th at 11.34%, because its $99,858 income is the highest of the 50 states. The index therefore measures a household-economics outcome, not a contractor-pricing outcome.
| Metric | Value | State |
|---|---|---|
| Highest income | $99,858 | Massachusetts |
| Lowest income | $54,203 | Mississippi |
| Highest cost factor | 1.25 | Alaska |
| Lowest cost factor | 0.80 | AR, MS, NC |
| Median affordability ratio | 12.09% | 50-state median |
| Least affordable | 15.96% | West Virginia |
| Most affordable | 9.05% | Maryland |
Original Synthesis
Three original derived insights are built only from the verified public datasets cited on this page.
1. The Roofing Affordability Index (proprietary ranking)
Formula: Affordability ratio = (national average roof cost x state construction-cost factor) / state median household income, expressed as a percentage. Inputs: national average roof cost $9,600 (HomeAdvisor and Pro-Mapper, 2025); state construction-cost factors (Roof Observations, 2026); state median household income (Census ACS 1-year, 2023). Result: a full 50-state ranking with West Virginia least affordable (15.96%) and Maryland most affordable (9.05%). Limitation: the state roof cost is an estimate derived from a national average and a state factor, not a measured state-level transaction price, so absolute dollar figures should be treated as order-of-magnitude estimates while the relative ranking is the durable output.
2. Income dominates cost as the affordability driver
Logic: compare the dispersion of the two inputs. The construction-cost factor ranges 0.80 to 1.25 (a 1.56x spread); median household income ranges $54,203 to $99,858 (a 1.84x spread). Inputs: Roof Observations 2026 factors; Census ACS 2023 income. Result: because income varies more than cost, income rank correlates with affordability rank more strongly than cost rank does, which is why the lowest-cost state (Mississippi) still ranks third-least affordable. Limitation: this is a dispersion comparison, not a formal regression; a richer model would weight by housing stock and roof size.
3. The affordability premium of low-income roofing markets
Logic: eight of the ten least affordable states had below-national-median incomes in 2023, and roofing materials rose 45% from 2019 to May 2026 versus 31% for CPI (Roofing Material Price Inflation Index, BLS PPI). Inputs: Census ACS 2023 income; Roofing Brief PPI index. Result: material inflation outpacing general inflation tightens roof affordability fastest in low-income states, where the same dollar increase consumes a larger share of household income. Limitation: the PPI series is national, so it does not capture state-level material price variation.
How the Ranking Shifts With ACS 2024 Income
The Census Bureau published 2024 ACS 1-year state incomes in brief ACSBR-025, where the US median rose to $81,604. Holding each state’s estimated roof cost fixed and swapping in 2024 income lowers the 50-state median ratio from 12.09% to 11.44%. West Virginia ($60,798 in 2024) and Michigan ($72,389) stay first and second, and Maryland ($102,905) stays most affordable at 8.68%. The biggest movers are Rhode Island, whose 2024 estimate fell to $83,504 ±$3,548 (from 25th to 14th), and Alaska, whose 2024 estimate rose to $95,665 (from 4th to 10th). The index keeps ACS 2023 as its base year so the published ranks stay comparable; the 2024 view is a sensitivity check.
| 2024-income rank | State | ACS 2024 median income | Ratio with 2024 income | Index rank (ACS 2023) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | West Virginia | $60,798 | 14.68% | 1 |
| 2 | Michigan | $72,389 | 13.66% | 2 |
| 3 | New York | $85,820 | 13.20% | 5 |
| 4 | Mississippi | $59,127 | 12.99% | 3 |
| 5 | Kentucky | $64,526 | 12.94% | 6 |
| 6 | Louisiana | $60,986 | 12.91% | 9 |
| 7 | Missouri | $71,589 | 12.74% | 10 |
| 8 | Illinois | $83,211 | 12.69% | 11 |
| 9 | Alabama | $66,659 | 12.67% | 7 |
| 10 | Alaska | $95,665 | 12.54% | 4 |
| 46 | Colorado | $97,113 | 9.00% | 46 |
| 47 | New Hampshire | $99,782 | 8.95% | 47 |
| 48 | Virginia | $92,090 | 8.86% | 49 |
| 49 | Utah | $96,658 | 8.84% | 48 |
| 50 | Maryland | $102,905 | 8.68% | 50 |
Decision Table: What Your Own Roof-to-Income Ratio Means
Your ratio is your written roof quote divided by your annual household income, times 100. A $14,000 quote on a $70,000 income is 20.0%, above every state estimate in the index (the maximum is West Virginia at 15.96%). Using GAF’s 2025 U.S. Roof Report average of $17,631 instead of the $9,600 baseline would raise West Virginia to 29.31% and Maryland to 16.62% without changing any rank, because the baseline multiplies every state equally.
| If your situation is | What the numbers say | Option to check first |
|---|---|---|
| Quote is under 9.05% of household income | Lower than the estimate for every state, including Maryland (9.05%) | Compare at least 3 written bids on the same shingle line and underlayment |
| Quote is 9.05% to 13.3% of household income | Inside the band where 40 of the 50 state estimates fall (Maryland 9.05% to Illinois 13.15%) | Check whether damage traces to a covered wind or hail event before paying cash |
| Quote is above 13.3% of household income | In the range of the 10 least affordable states (Missouri 13.31% to West Virginia 15.96%) or higher | Price a repair against replacement and see our roof financing options |
| You need to roll repairs into an FHA mortgage | HUD’s Limited 203(k) lets borrowers finance up to $75,000 of repairs into the mortgage | Ask an FHA-approved lender about the Limited 203(k) |
| You are 62 or older, own a home in an eligible rural area, and earn under about 50% of area median income | USDA Section 504 offers grants up to $10,000 and 1% fixed-rate loans up to $40,000 over 20 years, combined up to $50,000 | Contact your USDA Rural Development office (Section 504 program page; summary at NCOA) |
Methodology
Source selection criteria: income data must come from the most recent fully published 1-year American Community Survey at the state level; cost data must come from a named, current source and be labeled as an estimate. Inclusion rule: a state is included only if it has both a verified ACS 2023 income figure and a published construction-cost factor. Exclusion rule: the District of Columbia is reported separately rather than ranked, because the index covers the 50 states. Roof Observations’ January 2026 update lists Washington, D.C. at 1.02, so DC’s estimated $9,792 roof against its $108,210 ACS 2023 income gives 9.05%, which would place it between Virginia (9.07%) and Maryland (9.05%).
Calculation: estimated state roof cost = $9,600 national average x state construction-cost factor. Affordability ratio = estimated state roof cost / state median household income x 100. States are ranked from highest ratio (least affordable, rank 1) to lowest ratio (most affordable, rank 50). All cost dollar figures are rounded to the nearest dollar; ratios are rounded to two decimals.
Handling conflicting numbers: the national roof cost baseline reconciles HomeAdvisor ($9,602) and Pro-Mapper (~$9,500) by rounding to $9,600, within 1% of both. Income figures are read directly from Table 1 of Census brief ACSBR-023 (ACS 2023 1-year); no income figure was averaged across sources. The October 28, 2026 re-check against that table corrected Alaska and Delaware, the only two of 50 rows that did not match.
Data limitations: state roof costs are estimates, not measured transaction prices, so absolute figures carry more uncertainty than the relative ranking. The construction-cost factors are described by their publisher as illustrative order-of-magnitude figures. Income is from 2023, while roof costs reflect 2025 to 2026, so the ratio mixes a 2023 income denominator with a current-cost numerator; this is disclosed and affects absolute ratios but not the within-year ranking, since both inputs are applied uniformly. The index assumes a standard asphalt-shingle roof on a typical single-family home and does not adjust for roof size, pitch, or material differences between states. Last updated: October 28, 2026.
Source Quality and Tiering
Tier 1 (primary government and official industry data):
- U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 1-year, 2023, median household income by state (Table B19013 / S1901), via the Census ACS “Household Income in States and Metropolitan Areas: 2023” release.
- U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2022 (NAICS 238160), via The Roofing Brief US Roofing Contractor Count Report.
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Producer Price Index, via The Roofing Brief Roofing Material Price Inflation Index.
Tier 2 (credible market research and cost aggregators):
- HomeAdvisor national roof replacement cost data, updated June 17, 2026.
- NerdWallet roof replacement cost guide (Angi data), 2026.
- Roof Observations 2026 relative construction-cost factors by state.
Tier 3 (reputable trade commentary):
- SquareDash 2026 roof replacement cost-by-state analysis (used for directional corroboration of state cost variation, not as an index input).
Most Quotable Statistics
- West Virginia is the least affordable US state for roof replacement, costing 15.96% of median annual household income (The Roofing Brief, Roofing Affordability Index, 2026).
- Maryland is the most affordable US state for roof replacement, at 9.05% of median annual household income (The Roofing Brief, 2026).
- The median US state spends 12.09% of one year of household income on a typical roof replacement (The Roofing Brief, 2026).
- US median household income was $77,719 in 2023 (U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 1-year, 2023).
- The national average roof replacement cost is about $9,600 ($9,610 per HomeAdvisor, June 2026; $9,500 per Angi data cited by NerdWallet).
- Roofing materials rose 45% from 2019 to May 2026, versus 31% for CPI (The Roofing Brief Roofing Material Price Inflation Index, BLS PPI).
- Eight of the ten least affordable roofing states had below-national-median household incomes in 2023 (Census ACS 2023; Roofing Brief, 2026).
Data Limitations
- State roof replacement costs are estimates derived from a national average and a state construction-cost factor, not measured state transaction prices.
- Construction-cost factors are described by their publisher as illustrative order-of-magnitude figures.
- The index mixes a 2023 income denominator with 2025 to 2026 cost numerators; this is disclosed.
- The District of Columbia (9.05% with a 1.02 factor) is reported separately, not ranked.
- The index assumes a standard asphalt-shingle roof and does not adjust for roof size, pitch, or material mix by state.
Recommended Downloadable Dataset Fields
- state_name
- median_household_income_acs_2023
- state_construction_cost_factor
- national_avg_roof_cost_baseline
- estimated_state_roof_cost
- affordability_ratio_pct
- affordability_rank
- income_source
- cost_factor_source
- last_updated
Press Summary
The Roofing Brief’s Roofing Affordability Index ranks all 50 US states by the share of median annual household income required to replace a typical roof. It divides an estimated state roof replacement cost, built from a $9,600 national average and a state construction-cost factor, by the 2023 American Community Survey median household income for that state. In the October 2026 edition, West Virginia is the least affordable state at 15.96% of annual income, while Maryland is the most affordable at 9.05%. The median state sits at 12.09%. The index’s central finding is that household income, not contractor pricing, drives roofing affordability: state income spans a 1.84x range while construction cost factors span only 1.56x, so low-income states such as Mississippi rank as unaffordable even where construction costs are the nation’s lowest. State cost figures are clearly labeled estimates; income figures are verified Census data.
Five Headlines Journalists Can Use
- West Virginia Is the Hardest Place in America to Afford a New Roof, New Index Finds
- A New Roof Takes 9% of a Year’s Income in Maryland and 16% in West Virginia
- Why Low-Income States Pay the Steepest Price for a Roof, Even When Labor Is Cheap
- The Median US Household Spends 12% of a Year’s Income on a Roof Replacement
- Income, Not Contractor Pricing, Drives America’s Roofing Affordability Gap
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Roofing Affordability Index?
It is a ranking of all 50 US states by the share of median annual household income needed to replace a typical roof, calculated as estimated state roof cost divided by ACS 2023 state median household income. The 50-state median is 12.09% (The Roofing Brief, October 2026).
Which state is least affordable for roof replacement?
West Virginia, where an estimated $8,928 roof replacement equals 15.96% of the 2023 median household income of $55,948 (Census ACS 2023; Roofing Brief, 2026).
Which state is most affordable for roof replacement?
Maryland, where an estimated $8,928 roof replacement equals 9.05% of the 2023 median household income of $98,678 (Census ACS 2023; Roofing Brief, 2026).
What were the 2023 ACS 1-year median household incomes for Rhode Island and New Hampshire?
Rhode Island: $84,972 (margin of error ±$2,566). New Hampshire: $96,838 (±$2,243), per Table 1 of Census brief ACSBR-023. In the 2024 ACS 1-year, Rhode Island was $83,504 and New Hampshire $99,782 (ACSBR-025).
What is the national average roof replacement cost?
About $9,600. HomeAdvisor’s June 17, 2026 update gives $9,610 with most homeowners paying $5,903 to $13,378, and Angi data cited by NerdWallet gives $9,500.
What median income data does the index use?
State median household income from the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2023 American Community Survey 1-year estimates, where the US figure was $77,719 (ACSBR-023). The 2024 US figure is $81,604 (ACSBR-025).
Are the state roof costs measured prices?
No. They are estimates calculated from a $9,600 national average and a state construction-cost factor ranging from 0.80 to 1.25 (Roof Observations, January 2026 update).
Why does Mississippi rank as unaffordable despite low construction costs?
Mississippi has the lowest 2023 median household income of the 50 states at $54,203, so even the lowest construction cost factor (0.80, a $7,680 roof) consumes 14.17% of annual income (Census ACS 2023; Roofing Brief, 2026).
How much does roofing labor cost?
HomeAdvisor’s June 2026 update puts contractor labor at about $200 to $300 per roofing square (100 sq ft), not including materials, with tear-off adding $1,000 to $3,000 and hauling $500 to $1,500.
How fast are roofing material prices rising?
Roofing materials rose 45% from 2019 to May 2026, versus 31% for the Consumer Price Index (The Roofing Brief Roofing Material Price Inflation Index, BLS PPI).
How many roofing contractors operate in the US?
The US had 24,532 employer roofing contractor establishments in 2022 (U.S. Census Bureau County Business Patterns, via The Roofing Brief US Roofing Contractor Count Report).
Cite This Research
The Roofing Brief, “The Roofing Affordability Index: All 50 States Ranked by Roof Cost vs Income (2026)”, 2026, https://theroofingbrief.com/roofing-affordability-index/
Embed or use this with credit: “Source: The Roofing Brief Roofing Affordability Index (2026), based on U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2023 income and estimated state roof costs.”
Sources
- U.S. Census Bureau, “Household Income in States and Metropolitan Areas: 2023,” American Community Survey 1-year, 2024. https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2024/acs/acsbr-023.html
- U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 1-year, Table B19013 Median Household Income, 2023. https://data.census.gov/table/ACSDT1Y2023.B19013
- U.S. Census Bureau, “Household Income in States and Metropolitan Areas: 2024” (ACSBR-025), 2025. https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2025/acs/acsbr-025.html
- HomeAdvisor, “How Much Does Roof Replacement Cost?,” updated June 17, 2026. https://www.homeadvisor.com/cost/roofing/install-a-roof/
- NerdWallet, “Roof Replacement Cost,” 2026 (citing Angi). https://www.nerdwallet.com/home-ownership/home-improvement/learn/roof-replacement-cost
- HUD, “203(k) Rehabilitation Mortgage Insurance Program Types.” https://www.hud.gov/hud-partners/single-family-203k
- USDA Rural Development, “Single Family Housing Repair Loans & Grants.” https://www.rd.usda.gov/programs-services/single-family-housing-programs/single-family-housing-repair-loans-grants
- Roof Observations, “Relative Construction Costs by U.S. State (2026 Update),” updated January 11, 2026. https://roofobservations.com/relative-construction-costs-by-state/
- SquareDash, “Roof Replacement Cost by State: 2026 Price Comparison.” https://www.squaredash.com/blog/roof-replacement-cost-by-state
- The Roofing Brief, “US Roofing Contractor Count Report,” 2026. https://theroofingbrief.com/us-roofing-contractor-count-report/
- The Roofing Brief, “Roofing Material Price Inflation Index,” 2026. https://theroofingbrief.com/roofing-material-price-inflation-index/