Subscribe

INDUSTRY REPORTS · June 30, 2026

Does a New Roof Increase Home Value? Roof Replacement ROI and Resale Value Report (2025 Cost vs. Value Data)

A new roof can increase home value by $21,501: asphalt roofs recouped 68% and metal 50% at sale in the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, with state data.

By The Roofing Brief Team. Last reviewed: October 2026.

A new roof can increase home value by about $21,501, the resale value Zonda’s 2025 Cost vs. Value Report assigns to a $31,871 asphalt shingle replacement, a 68% recoup, so a new roof adds about two-thirds of its cost to home value and returns a smaller share at resale than curb-appeal projects like a new garage door or front door. The figures below are the cost-recouped percentages, job costs, and resale values published in Zonda’s 2025 Cost vs. Value Report (the 38th annual edition, released September 18, 2025), the standard industry citation for remodeling return on investment, alongside the National Association of Realtors 2025 Remodeling Impact Report. All recoup figures are point-of-sale estimates from contractor cost data and Realtor-estimated resale value, not realized sale prices. Our Arizona roof cost guide applies the same report to Phoenix and Tucson.

Executive Summary

  • An asphalt shingle roof replacement cost a national average of $31,871 and added $21,501 in resale value for a 68% recoup in the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, corroborated by a state-median average of 67.5% derived from the same report by Fixr (Source: JLC 2025 Cost vs. Value Report; Fixr, 2025).
  • A metal roof replacement cost a national average of $51,865 and added $25,972 for a 50% recoup in the 2025 report, 18 percentage points below asphalt shingle (Source: JLC 2025 Cost vs. Value Report).
  • In the prior 2024 (37th annual) report, asphalt shingle roofing cost a national average of $30,680 and added $17,461 in resale value for a 56.9% recoup (JLC rounds it to 57%), while metal roofing cost $49,928 and added $24,034 for a 48.1% recoup (Source: JLC 2024 Cost vs. Value Report).
  • Roofing recoup varies sharply by state, from a high of 86.5% in Utah to a low of 21.6% in Nebraska in the 2025 report, a spread of nearly 65 percentage points (Source: Fixr, citing 2025 CvV).
  • Roofing returns less at resale than every exterior replacement project in the top of the 2025 ranking: garage door replacement recouped 267.7%, fiber-cement siding 113.7%, and vinyl siding 96.5% (Source: Zonda, 2025).
  • In the National Association of Realtors 2025 Remodeling Impact Report, new roofing earned a Joy Score of 10 out of 10, and 37% of Realtors recommended sellers install new roofing before listing, third behind painting the entire home (50%) and painting one room (41%) (Source: NAR, April 9, 2025).
  • 43% of Realtors reported increased buyer demand for new roofing over the prior two years, second only to kitchen upgrades at 48%, in the 2025 NAR report (Source: NAR, 2025).

Key Findings

  • The 2025 Cost vs. Value Report is the 38th annual edition, released September 18, 2025, covering 28 remodeling projects across 115 U.S. markets per Zonda (JLC’s index page says 119) (Source: Zonda, 2025).
  • Asphalt shingle roof replacement cost $31,871, added $21,501 in resale value, and recouped 68% nationally in the 2025 report (Source: JLC 2025 CvV).
  • Metal roof replacement cost $51,865, added $25,972, and recouped 50% nationally in the 2025 report (Source: JLC 2025 CvV).
  • The state-median asphalt roofing recoup was 67.5% nationally in the 2025 dataset compiled by Fixr from the Cost vs. Value Report (Source: Fixr, 2025).
  • Utah (86.5%), Nevada (85.6%), and Washington, D.C. (85.2%) led all states for asphalt roofing recoup in the 2025 report (Source: Fixr, 2025). For city-level figures, see our Salt Lake City roof resale data.
  • Nebraska (21.6%), Kansas (34.4%), and North Dakota (35.6%) recorded the lowest asphalt roofing recoup in the 2025 report (Source: Fixr, 2025).
  • The East South Central division (Alabama, Kentucky, Mississippi, Tennessee) averaged the highest regional asphalt recoup at 81% in the 2025 dataset (Source: Fixr, 2025).
  • In the 2024 report, asphalt shingle roofing cost a national average of $30,680 and metal roofing $49,928, a difference of $19,248 in job cost (Source: JLC 2024 CvV).
  • Garage door replacement topped the 2025 exterior ranking at 267.7% recouped on a $4,672 job cost (Source: Zonda, 2025).
  • Fiber-cement siding replacement recouped 113.7% in 2025 on a $21,485 job cost, and vinyl siding recouped 96.5% on a $17,950 job cost (Source: Zonda, 2025).
  • Vinyl window replacement recouped 68.5% and wood window replacement 61.2% nationally in the 2025 report (Source: getwindowcost.com citing JLC 2025 CvV).
  • New roofing does not appear on the NAR 2025 report’s published cost-recovery list, which runs from a new steel front door (100%) and closet renovation (83%) down to a bathroom renovation (50%) (Source: NAR 2025 Remodeling Impact Report presentation).
  • New roofing earned a Joy Score of 10 out of 10 in the NAR 2025 report, tied with an added primary bedroom suite and a kitchen upgrade (Source: NAR, 2025).
  • A typical architectural asphalt shingle replacement runs $15,000 to $30,000, or $5.00 to $7.00 per square foot installed, in Bill Ragan Roofing’s 2026 price table (Source: Bill Ragan Roofing); our 2026 roofing cost report uses $5 to $8 per square foot.

What the Cost vs. Value Report Measures

The Cost vs. Value Report, published annually since 1988 by Zonda (the data company that owns Remodeling and the Journal of Light Construction), compares the average contractor cost of a defined remodeling project against the resale value real estate professionals estimate it adds. The cost-recouped percentage is resale value divided by job cost. A value below 100% means the project, on average, returns less than it costs at the point of sale. The 2025 edition, the 38th annual, covers 28 projects across roughly 115 U.S. markets and was released September 18, 2025 (Source: Zonda, 2025). The report is a proprietary industry dataset, classified here as Tier 2, but it is the standard citation for remodeling ROI and is used as such throughout this report.

Two caveats apply to every figure below. First, the “resale value” is an estimate provided by real estate professionals, not a realized transaction price, so it reflects perceived market value rather than an audited outcome. Second, the report defines each project to a fixed specification (for roofing, a 30-square tear-off and replacement with new underlayment), so a homeowner’s actual recoup depends on local labor rates, roof complexity, and material choice.

National Roofing Recoup: Asphalt vs. Metal

Asphalt shingle roofing recoups a higher share of its cost than metal roofing in every recent edition of the Cost vs. Value Report. In 2025, asphalt returned 68% of its $31,871 cost at resale, while metal returned 50% of its $51,865 cost, an 18-point gap. Metal carries a far higher job cost, but buyers do not assign it a proportionally higher resale premium.

Project Edition National job cost Resale value Cost recouped
Asphalt shingle roofing 2025 (38th) $31,871 $21,501 68%
Metal roofing 2025 (38th) $51,865 $25,972 50%
Asphalt shingle roofing 2024 (37th) $30,680 $17,461 56.9%
Metal roofing 2024 (37th) $49,928 $24,034 48.1%

Sources: 2025 figures from the Journal of Light Construction 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, with the national asphalt recoup independently corroborated at a state-median 67.5% by Fixr; 2024 figures from the JLC 2024 Cost vs. Value Report national page (asphalt $30,680 job cost, $17,461 resale; metal $49,928, $24,034). An earlier version of this page listed the 2024 asphalt resale value as $17,807, which does not match the JLC 2024 national page; it was corrected on October 28, 2026. The primary jlconline.com pages returned access errors to direct automated retrieval and were read through a text-rendering proxy of the same live pages, then spot-confirmed against Fixr’s independent restatement.

The asphalt advantage is structural. In the 2025 report, metal roofing cost 63% more than asphalt ($51,865 versus $31,871) but added only 21% more resale value ($25,972 versus $21,501), so its recoup came in 18 points lower. The same pattern held in 2024, when metal cost 63% more but returned only about 9 points less. Buyers do reward metal’s durability, energy performance, and lower insurance risk in some markets, but the Cost vs. Value methodology captures only the resale-value estimate at the point of sale, not the multi-decade cost savings a metal roof can deliver to the owner who keeps it.

Regional and State Differences in Roofing ROI

The single largest driver of roofing recoup is location. Using city-level figures from the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, Fixr calculated a median asphalt shingle recoup for each state and found a spread of nearly 65 percentage points between the highest and lowest states. Western and southern states cluster at the top; several Plains and Midwestern states sit at the bottom.

Rank State or district Asphalt roofing cost recouped (2025)
1 Utah 86.5%
2 Nevada 85.6%
3 Washington, D.C. 85.2%
4 Arkansas 80.4%
5 Virginia 79.2%
National (state-median) United States 67.5%
47 Iowa 41.2%
48 North Dakota 35.6%
49 Kansas 34.4%
50 Nebraska 21.6%

Source: Fixr, derived from the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report. The Cost vs. Value Report also publishes figures for each of the nine U.S. Census divisions. The table below gives the 2025 asphalt shingle roofing job cost, resale value, and recoup for every division, read from the Journal of Light Construction regional report pages.

Census division Job cost Resale value Cost recouped (2025)
Pacific $36,391 $27,742 76.2%
Mountain $28,475 $20,427 71.7%
South Atlantic $32,253 $22,535 69.9%
East North Central $29,253 $20,252 69.2%
West South Central $27,116 $18,478 68.1%
East South Central $25,939 $21,012 81.0%
New England $35,701 $22,346 62.6%
Middle Atlantic $37,201 $21,680 58.3%
West North Central $30,693 $16,650 54.2%

Source: Journal of Light Construction 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, regional pages (Pacific, Mountain, and other division-level URLs), read through a text-rendering proxy of the live pages. The East South Central division (Alabama, Kentucky, Mississippi, Tennessee) led at 81%, while the West North Central division (the Plains states) trailed at 54.2%, the same direction Fixr’s state-median analysis shows. The pattern tracks housing demand: in active, supply-constrained western and southern markets, buyers price a new roof close to its cost, while in slower Plains markets a new roof is treated more as expected maintenance than as added value. New England and the Middle Atlantic recoup below the national average despite high job costs ($35,701 and $37,201), because higher labor costs raise the denominator faster than buyers raise the resale estimate.

One limitation: Fixr’s state figures are medians of the cities the Cost vs. Value Report samples within each state (the 2025 edition samples 115 markets per Zonda, and Fixr’s state medians run from 21.6% to 86.5%), and some states had limited city coverage, so individual-state percentages carry more uncertainty than the national figure. The direction of the regional pattern, west and south high, Midwest low, is consistent across editions and is the more reliable takeaway than any single state’s exact percentage.

How Roofing Compares to Other Exterior Projects

Within the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, asphalt roofing (68%) returns less at resale than the curb-appeal replacement projects that lead the ranking: garage door replacement (267.7% on $4,672), steel entry door (216.4% on $2,435) and manufactured stone veneer (207.9% on $11,702), per Zonda’s top 10 table. Exterior replacements held 8 of the top 10 spots, and neither roofing project made that list.

Exterior project (2025) National job cost Resale value Cost recouped
Garage door replacement $4,672 $12,507 267.7%
Fiber-cement siding replacement $21,485 $24,420 113.7%
Vinyl siding replacement $17,950 $17,313 96.5%
Vinyl window replacement (10 windows) $20,091 $13,766 68.5%
Asphalt shingle roofing replacement $31,871 $21,501 68%
Wood window replacement (10 windows) $24,376 $14,912 61.2%
Metal roofing replacement $51,865 $25,972 50%

Sources: garage door and siding figures from Zonda (2025); window figures from getwindowcost.com citing JLC 2025 CvV; roofing figures from the JLC 2025 CvV report. The ranking shows the core resale truth: low-cost cosmetic upgrades recoup more than 100% because a $4,672 garage door visibly transforms a facade for little money, while a roof, though essential, is a large cost that buyers expect to be sound rather than a feature they pay a premium for. Asphalt shingle roofing (68%) lands just above vinyl windows (68.5%, essentially tied) and ahead of wood windows (61.2%), but below both siding categories; metal roofing sits at the bottom of the exterior list on a recoup basis because of its high job cost. Cosmetic choices still shape buyer perception, a factor our reports on whether roof color affects resale value and the best roof color for resale value examine in detail.

Realtor Perspective: NAR Remodeling Impact Report

The National Association of Realtors 2025 Remodeling Impact Report, released April 9, 2025 with the National Association of the Remodeling Industry, rated new roofing a Joy Score of 10 out of 10 and found that 37% of Realtors recommend sellers install new roofing before listing. It does not publish a cost-recovery figure for roofing: its cost-recovery chart lists 12 projects, from a new steel front door (100%) to a bathroom renovation (50%), and new roofing is not among them.

  • 37% of Realtors recommended new roofing as a pre-listing project, behind painting the entire home (50%) and painting one interior room (41%), and ahead of a kitchen upgrade (30%) (Source: NAR 2025 Remodeling Impact Report presentation).
  • New roofing earned a Joy Score of 10 out of 10, tying the top satisfaction tier with a primary-bedroom-suite addition and a kitchen upgrade (Source: NAR press release, April 9, 2025).
  • 43% of Realtors reported increased buyer demand for new roofing over the prior two years, second only to kitchen upgrades at 48% and ahead of bathroom renovations at 35% (Source: NAR, 2025).

An earlier version of this page described the NAR 37% figure as a cost-recovery estimate. It is the share of Realtors recommending the project before a sale; the correction was made on October 28, 2026. For a dollar return on a roof, the Cost vs. Value figures above (68% asphalt, 50% metal in 2025) remain the published national benchmark.

Roof Replacement Cost Ranges

A typical architectural asphalt shingle replacement runs $15,000 to $30,000, or $5.00 to $7.00 per square foot installed, in Bill Ragan Roofing’s 2026 table, while standing seam metal runs $8 to $39 per square foot per This Old House. Recoup percentages are only meaningful against these job costs, which align with the Cost vs. Value job-cost ranges.

Roof type Installed cost per square foot Typical total range Source
3-tab asphalt shingle $4.00 to $5.00 $8,000 to $12,000 Bill Ragan Roofing, 2026 table
Architectural asphalt shingle $5.00 to $7.00 $15,000 to $30,000 Bill Ragan Roofing, 2026 table
Steel exposed-fastener metal $4.50 to $6.50 $15,000 to $25,000 Bill Ragan Roofing, 2026 table
Steel standing seam metal $16.00 (Bill Ragan); $8 to $39 (This Old House) $40,000 to $60,000 Bill Ragan Roofing, 2026; This Old House
Cost vs. Value national spec, asphalt (2025) n/a $31,871 job cost JLC 2025 CvV
Cost vs. Value national spec, metal (2025) n/a $51,865 job cost JLC 2025 CvV

Shingle grade moves the asphalt price from $4.00 to $5.00 per square foot for 3-tab to $8.00 to $10.00 for luxury shingles in Bill Ragan’s 2026 table, and panel type moves metal from $4.50 to $6.50 (exposed-fastener steel) to $16.00 (steel standing seam). The Cost vs. Value job costs sit toward the higher end of these ranges because the report specifies a full tear-off, new underlayment, and a defined roof size rather than the least-expensive possible job.

Original Synthesis

The following insights are derived only from the verified public and industry datasets cited above. Each states its logic, inputs, and limitations.

1. The asphalt-over-metal recoup gap, quantified

Logic: recoup percentage equals resale value divided by job cost. Inputs: 2024 Cost vs. Value national figures (asphalt $30,680 cost / $17,461 resale / 56.9%; metal $49,928 cost / $24,034 resale / 48.1%) and 2025 figures (asphalt $31,871 / $21,501 / 68%; metal $51,865 / $25,972 / 50%). Result: in 2024 the asphalt-over-metal gap was 8.8 points; in 2025 it widened to 18 points. The widening is driven by asphalt’s recoup jumping from 56.9% to 68% between editions while metal moved only from 48.1% to 50%. Limitation: the year-over-year change partly reflects a change in the report’s defined job scope, not only market movement, so the absolute recoup levels are more comparable within an edition than across editions.

2. A roofing-ROI regional index

Logic: rank the 2025 state-median asphalt recoup figures and group by Census division. Inputs: Fixr’s state-level 2025 dataset. Result: the top quintile is dominated by the Mountain (Utah 86.5%, Nevada 85.6%) and South Atlantic (D.C. 85.2%, Virginia 79.2%) divisions, while the bottom quintile is concentrated in the West North Central division (Nebraska 21.6%, Kansas 34.4%, North Dakota 35.6%, Iowa 41.2%). A homeowner in the top-quintile states recoups roughly four times the share that a Nebraska homeowner does. Limitation: state medians are built from limited city samples and should be read as directional, not precise to the tenth of a percent.

3. Roofing’s rank among exterior projects

Logic: order the 2025 exterior projects by cost recouped. Inputs: 2025 figures for garage door, siding, windows, and roofing. Result: of seven exterior replacement categories, asphalt roofing ranks fourth (essentially tied with vinyl windows) and metal roofing ranks last, behind garage door (267.7%), fiber-cement siding (113.7%), and vinyl siding (96.5%). The takeaway for sellers: if the existing roof is sound, dollars spent on a garage door or siding return more at resale than a roof replacement. For the cost of a new roof and siding done as one project, including combined Cost vs. Value recoup, see our worked totals. Limitation: this ranks projects on resale recoup only and ignores condition. A failing roof can block a sale entirely or trigger buyer credits, so its practical value to a seller with a worn roof is higher than its recoup percentage implies.

Decision Table: Replace the Roof Before Selling?

The net figures below apply each state’s 2025 median asphalt recoup (Fixr) to the national $31,871 Cost vs. Value job, so they are approximations of the cost a seller does not get back at sale, not quotes.

If your situation is What the 2025 data shows Option to price first
You sell in a state with a median asphalt recoup of 80% or more (Utah 86.5%, Nevada 85.6%, D.C. 85.2%, Arkansas 80.4%) A $31,871 job returns about $25,624 to $27,568, leaving $4,303 to $6,247 unrecovered Replacement before listing costs the least net of resale here
You sell in a state at or below 41.2% (Iowa 41.2%, North Dakota 35.6%, Kansas 34.4%, Nebraska 21.6%) The same job returns about $6,884 to $13,131, leaving $18,740 to $24,987 unrecovered Get a repair bid and a replacement bid, and compare both with the credit a buyer asks for after inspection
You are choosing metal or asphalt and expect to sell within a few years Metal leaves $25,893 unrecovered ($51,865 minus $25,972); asphalt leaves $10,370 ($31,871 minus $21,501) Asphalt, unless you plan to stay long enough to use metal’s longer service life
The roof is sound and you have about $5,000 for pre-listing work Garage door replacement recouped 267.7% on a $4,672 job; steel entry door 216.4% on $2,435 Spend on those first and disclose the roof’s age and condition
The roof has storm damage from wind or hail Cost vs. Value does not model insurance; a covered claim can change the net cost to the seller Read our guide to filing an insurance claim for roof damage before signing a replacement contract

Methodology

Source selection prioritized the Cost vs. Value Report as the authoritative remodeling-ROI dataset and the NAR Remodeling Impact Report for Realtor-side context. The primary Cost vs. Value pages on jlconline.com returned access errors to direct automated retrieval, so the national and nine regional roofing figures were read from those same live pages through a text-rendering proxy and then spot-confirmed against independent restatements: Fixr corroborated the national asphalt recoup (state-median 67.5% versus the report’s 68%) and the top region (East South Central at 81%). Comparison-project figures came from Zonda’s own press materials (garage door, siding) and getwindowcost.com (windows), each citing the 2025 report. The 2024 national roofing dollar figures were checked against the JLC 2024 national page on October 28, 2026, which corrected the asphalt resale value to $17,461. Where earlier drafts found conflicting window percentages (73.4% and 75.5% were regional or loose roundings), the national 2025 figures of 68.5% (vinyl) and 61.2% (wood) were used. No recoup percentage in this report was invented or calculated from assumptions; all are published Cost vs. Value or NAR figures retrieved from a real source. NAR figures were re-read from the 2025 Remodeling Impact Report presentation on October 28, 2026. Last updated: October 28, 2026.

Source Quality and Tiering

Tier 1 (primary or official bodies): National Association of Realtors and National Association of the Remodeling Industry, 2025 Remodeling Impact Report (survey of Realtors, NARI members and consumers).

Tier 2 (proprietary industry dataset, credible market research, public-company data): Zonda / Journal of Light Construction 2025 and 2024 Cost vs. Value Report (the standard industry citation for remodeling ROI, used throughout despite being proprietary); This Old House cost data.

Tier 3 (reputable expert commentary and trade restatements): Fixr state-level ROI analysis derived from Cost vs. Value; getwindowcost.com; Bill Ragan Roofing 2026 price table.

Most Quotable Statistics

  • Asphalt shingle roofing cost $31,871 and recouped 68% of cost at resale nationally in the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report (Source: JLC 2025 CvV).
  • Metal roofing cost $51,865 and recouped 50%, 18 points below asphalt, in the 2025 report (Source: JLC 2025 CvV).
  • Roofing recoup ranged from 86.5% in Utah to 21.6% in Nebraska in 2025, a near-65-point spread (Source: Fixr, 2025).
  • In 2024, asphalt roofing cost $30,680 and added $17,461 in resale value, a 56.9% recoup (Source: JLC 2024 CvV).
  • Garage door replacement recouped 267.7% in 2025, the highest of any project, versus roofing’s ~68% (Source: Zonda, 2025).
  • New roofing earned a 10-out-of-10 Joy Score, and 37% of Realtors recommended it before listing, in the NAR 2025 Remodeling Impact Report (Source: NAR/NARI, 2025).
  • 43% of Realtors reported higher buyer demand for new roofing over the prior two years (Source: NAR, 2025).

Data Limitations

  • The Cost vs. Value resale figures are Realtor estimates of value added, not realized sale prices, so they reflect perceived rather than transacted value.
  • The jlconline.com Cost vs. Value pages block automated retrieval (HTTP 403 on October 28, 2026), so the 2025 national and nine regional roofing figures were read through a text-rendering proxy and cross-checked against Fixr’s 67.5% state median and Zonda’s top 10 table.
  • State-level recoup figures are medians of limited city samples and should be read as directional.
  • NAR’s 2025 report publishes no cost-recovery figure for new roofing; its 37% roofing figure is the share of Realtors recommending the project before a sale.
  • Year-over-year roofing recoup jumped from 56.9% (2024) to 68% (2025) for asphalt, partly reflecting a change in the report’s defined job scope, so cross-edition comparisons should be read with caution.
  • Installed cost ranges ($4.00 to $10.00 per square foot for asphalt grades, $4.50 to $39 for metal) come from Bill Ragan Roofing’s 2026 table and This Old House, not from the Cost vs. Value specification.

Recommended Downloadable Dataset Fields

  • project_name (e.g., asphalt shingle roofing, metal roofing, vinyl siding)
  • report_edition_year (2024 or 2025)
  • geography_level (national, Census division, state)
  • geography_name
  • job_cost_usd
  • resale_value_usd
  • cost_recouped_pct
  • source_name and source_url
  • source_tier (1, 2, or 3)
  • confirmation_status (primary, restated, proxy-read)

Press Summary

A new roof is one of the largest exterior projects a homeowner can take on, and it returns less at resale than nearly every cheaper curb-appeal upgrade. In Zonda’s 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, the 38th annual edition, asphalt shingle roofing recouped about 68% of its cost at resale nationally, while metal roofing recouped about 50%, a gap driven by metal’s much higher job cost rather than weaker buyer interest. Recoup varies sharply by location, from 86.5% in Utah to 21.6% in Nebraska, with western and southern states recovering the most and Plains states the least. By comparison, garage door replacement recouped 267.7% and fiber-cement siding 113.7% in the same report, placing roofing in the middle of the exterior pack. The National Association of Realtors’ 2025 Remodeling Impact Report rated new roofing a perfect 10 for homeowner joy, 37% of Realtors recommended it before listing, and 43% reported higher buyer demand for it. The data points to a consistent conclusion: a roof is essential and highly satisfying, but it is maintenance buyers expect rather than a premium feature they pay extra for.

Five Headlines Journalists Can Use

  • New Roof, Old Truth: Homeowners Recoup About 68% of an Asphalt Roof at Resale in 2025
  • Metal Roofs Cost the Most and Return the Least Among Exterior Projects
  • From Utah to Nebraska: Roofing ROI Swings 65 Points by State
  • A Garage Door Beats a New Roof Four-to-One on Resale Recoup
  • Realtors Rate a New Roof a Perfect 10 for Joy, and 37% Tell Sellers to Replace It Before Listing

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does a new roof increase home value?

In the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, a $31,871 asphalt shingle replacement added $21,501 in resale value (68% recouped), and a $51,865 metal roof added $25,972 (50%). The 2024 edition put asphalt at $17,461 on $30,680 (56.9%).

Does a metal roof return more than asphalt at resale?

No. Metal roofing recouped 50% in 2025 versus 68% for asphalt, because metal’s $51,865 job cost is far higher without a proportional resale premium (Source: JLC 2025 CvV).

Which state has the best roofing ROI?

Utah led at 86.5% asphalt recoup in the 2025 dataset, followed by Nevada at 85.6% and Washington, D.C. at 85.2% (Source: Fixr, 2025).

Which states have the worst roofing ROI?

Nebraska was lowest at 21.6%, with Kansas at 34.4% and North Dakota at 35.6% in the 2025 dataset (Source: Fixr, 2025).

What is the national average roofing ROI?

The 2025 Cost vs. Value Report puts the national asphalt recoup at 68%, corroborated by Fixr’s state-median of 67.5% (Source: JLC 2025 CvV; Fixr, 2025).

How does roofing compare to siding for resale value?

Siding returns more: fiber-cement siding recouped 113.7% and vinyl siding 96.5% in 2025, both above asphalt roofing’s 68% (Source: Zonda, 2025).

How does roofing compare to replacement windows?

Asphalt roofing (68%) and vinyl windows (68.5%) were essentially tied in the 2025 report, while wood windows recouped 61.2%, below asphalt roofing (Source: getwindowcost.com citing 2025 CvV).

What does the NAR report say about new roofing?

NAR’s 2025 Remodeling Impact Report gave new roofing a Joy Score of 10 out of 10; 37% of Realtors recommended it before listing and 43% saw higher buyer demand for it. The report publishes no cost-recovery percentage for roofing.

What does a new roof cost?

Architectural asphalt shingles run $5.00 to $7.00 per square foot, or $15,000 to $30,000, in Bill Ragan Roofing’s 2026 table; standing seam metal runs $8 to $39 per square foot per This Old House.

Does a new roof help a home sell faster?

No dataset cited here measures days on market. 43% of Realtors reported increased buyer demand for new roofing in the 2025 NAR report, the second-highest share after kitchen upgrades (48%).

Cite This Research

The Roofing Brief, “Roof Replacement Return on Investment and Resale Value Report (2025 Cost vs. Value Data)”, 2026, https://theroofingbrief.com/roof-replacement-roi-resale-value-report/

Embed or use with credit: “According to The Roofing Brief’s analysis of the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, asphalt shingle roofing recoups about 68% of its cost at resale nationally versus about 50% for metal roofing.”

Sources

  1. Journal of Light Construction (Zonda), “2025 Cost vs. Value Report” national and regional project pages (38th annual), https://www.jlconline.com/cost-vs-value/2025/
  2. Zonda, “2025 Cost vs. Value Report” overview (38th annual, released September 18, 2025), https://zondahome.com/2025-cost-vs-value-report/
  3. Zonda / PR Newswire, “Zonda’s 38th Annual Cost vs. Value Report Confirms Exterior Projects Continue to Deliver the Highest ROI,” 2025, link
  4. Fixr, “Asphalt Shingle Roof ROI by State in 2025,” derived from the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, https://www.fixr.com/articles/asphalt-shingle-roofing-roi-by-state
  5. getwindowcost.com, “Window Replacement ROI,” citing the JLC 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, https://www.getwindowcost.com/window-replacement-roi
  6. This Old House, “Standing Seam Metal Roof Cost,” 2025, https://www.thisoldhouse.com/roofing/standing-seam-metal-roof-cost
  7. National Association of Realtors and NARI, “2025 Remodeling Impact Report” presentation, PDF
  8. Journal of Light Construction (Zonda), “2024 Cost vs. Value Report” national page, https://www.jlconline.com/cost-vs-value/2024/
  9. National Association of Realtors, “Top Remodeling Projects for Homeowner Satisfaction and Cost Recovery Revealed in NAR Report,” 2025, nar.realtor
  10. Bill Ragan Roofing, “What’s the Average Cost to Replace a Roof?,” 2026 price table, https://www.billraganroofing.com/blog/average-cost-replace-roof